Evil at the Door

20/201h 25mMay 30, 2026
AI-Generated Summary

The true story of Kenya Monheim, a 19-year-old woman whose disappearance in Denver in 2011 shocked a community and led to one of the most harrowing investigations in Colorado history. After being last seen leaving a nightclub with a man named Chad Davis, Kenya vanished—only to reappear in surveillance footage hours later at a hotel and gas station, where she was seen with a man named Travis Forbes. Though Forbes claimed to be a good Samaritan, his story unraveled under scrutiny: he was seen disconnecting security cameras, hiding a cooler in a bakery freezer, and fleeing to Texas with a stolen car. Months later, a second brutal attack in Fort Collins—where a woman was beaten, doused in bleach, and set on fire—raised chilling parallels. When DNA from the second victim matched Travis Forbes, investigators finally had a breakthrough. After a tense interrogation, Forbes confessed to killing Kenya, burying her in a remote field in northeastern Colorado, and also admitted to assaulting Lydia Tillman. His confession, secured through a deal to avoid the death penalty, brought closure to Kenya’s family—but not before they endured years of anguish, hope, and the devastating reality of a daughter’s disappearance. The case ultimately revealed a predator who exploited vulnerability, manipulated trust, and evaded justice for months—until forensic science and relentless investigation caught up with him.

Key Takeaways
1

Travis Forbes led police to Kenya Monheim's buried body in northeastern Colorado after confessing to her murder in exchange for avoiding the death penalty.

2

DNA from Lydia Tillman’s fingernails matched Travis Forbes, linking him to a second violent attack and confirming he was a serial predator.

3

Forbes was seen on surveillance with Kenya at a gas station, then later with a cooler and bleach in a bakery freezer—evidence of a calculated effort to destroy evidence.

4

Despite no body or direct DNA match initially, investigators used behavioral patterns, digital trails, and a psychological profile to build a case against Forbes.

5

Lydia Tillman survived her attack, awoke from a coma, and publicly forgave her attacker—delivering a victim impact statement that stunned the courtroom.

…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus

Chapters
0:00
2 min

The Disappearance of Kenya Monheim

This is The Unthinkable. You don't know what evil looks like till it comes knocking on your door.

Highlight
2:20
4 min

The Good Samaritan Who Wasn't

Travis Forbes claims he helped Kenya after seeing her talking to a homeless man. He says she left with a mysterious man named Dan, but his story is riddled with inconsistencies. Surveillance footage shows him acting suspiciously.

6:40
5 min

The Bakery and the Cooler

Police discover Travis Forbes tampered with security cameras at a bakery where he made gluten-free granola bars. Footage reveals him bringing a white cooler into the freezer and using bleach—evidence of a cover-up.

11:40
5 min

The Van, the Fire, and the Fleeing

Travis is spotted in Texas with a stolen car, using a fake name. Police track him down and arrest him for auto theft. He’s released after his friend drops charges, but investigators keep him under surveillance.

16:40
5 min

The Fort Collins Fire and the Second Attack

A woman was brutally beaten, allegedly doused in bleach and her apartment set on fire. And to me it was like, boy that's weird. I wonder if they're looking at Travis.

Highlight
High-Impact Quotes
Travis Forbes? You caused me no harm. My spirit, my soul and my mind remain untouched. May you find peace in this life.
Lydia Tillman81:59
sure I fit in. Really? Yes. A sociopath has no empathy. They can actually kill somebody and not feel anything about it as a sociopath.
Travis Forbes60:58
I had sex with her while she was passed out. She wakes up and is pissed at him because he had sex with her without a condom. She started hitting me, and I started hitting her back.
Travis Forbes74:53
Speakers

Hosts

Deborah RobertsDavid Muir

Guests

Tony LeeMaria MonheimMonica PooleSivaJacqueline ShackleyDetective Lou EstradaDetective Nash GuruleLydia TillmanWilliam Tillman
Topics Discussed
missing persons investigation95%serial predator90%forensic DNA evidence88%cold case breakthrough85%victim impact statement82%sociopath behavior80%surveillance footage78%trauma recovery75%
People & Brands

Kenya Monheim

person

120xNeutral

Travis Forbes

person

110xNegative

Tony Lee

person

45xPositive

Lydia Tillman

person

35xPositive

Denver

place

25xNeutral

Detective Nash Gurule

person

20xNeutral

Fort Collins

place

15xNeutral

Monica Poole

person

15xNeutral

Siva

person

12xNeutral

Jacqueline Shackley

person

10xNeutral

Start discovering podcast insights today

Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.

No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime