Mafia Cops | Murder For Hire | 2
In the aftermath of a botched assassination attempt on Lucchese underboss Anthony 'Gaspipe' Casso, the mobster turns to corrupt NYPD detectives Stephen Caracapa and Louis Eppolito for help—only to discover they're not just informants, but active partners in his vendetta. What begins as a simple request to track down his would-be killers spirals into a deadly collaboration: the cops deliver Jimmy Heidel, then help Casso hunt down Nicky Guido and Bob Baring, with the latter being mistakenly killed due to a case of mistaken identity. The real Nicky Guido, a petty criminal, is eventually arrested and imprisoned, but Casso remains unsatisfied. As the bodies pile up, Caracapa and Eppolito escalate from intelligence brokers to hitmen, assassinating Gambino captain Eddie Lino in a staged traffic stop—killing him with cold precision and no remorse. The episode reveals a chilling truth: the mafia didn’t just corrupt the police, they weaponized them. What started as a personal revenge mission becomes a systemic collapse of justice, where the line between law enforcement and organized crime vanishes entirely. Casso’s quest for vengeance exposes a deeper rot: the NYPD’s internal corruption was so entrenched that detectives could manipulate criminal databases with impunity, cover their tracks, and even demand a retainer for future access.
Corrupt NYPD detectives Caracapa and Eppolito sold confidential police data to mobsters, enabling targeted assassinations.
Cassos attempted murder led to a chain of mistaken identities—innocent Nicky Guido was killed instead of the real target.
The detectives transitioned from intelligence brokers to hitmen, assassinating Gambino captain Eddie Lino in a staged police stop.
Cassos demand for exclusive access to police intelligence forced the detectives to cut out intermediaries like Burton Kaplan.
The corruption was systemic: detectives manipulated criminal databases without oversight, using case numbers to hide their searches.
…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus
The Dog That Started It All
Anthony Casso shoots Jimmy Heidel's Doberman after the dog attacks bystanders, setting off a chain of events that leads to a failed assassination attempt on Casso himself.
The Shooting That Changed Everything
“He's survived worse than this. He knows he'll live, but he's determined that the men who tried to kill him won't.”
The Accusation and the Informants
Casso suspects the Gambinos behind the hit but lacks proof. He turns to corrupt cop contacts via Burton Kaplan to get evidence.
The Kidnapping of Jimmy Heidel
“They've cuffed him, bound his feet with duct tape, and stuffed his mouth with a handkerchief. Still, despite all their precautions, they had to knock him out because he was making such a racket.”
The Confession and the Lie
Heidel confesses under torture that the Gambinos ordered the hit. Casso uses the confession to assert dominance over rival families.
“Keeping pace with the vehicle, Caracapa fires another six rounds through the window to make sure Lino's dead.”
“I can't understand why anyone would want to hurt Nikki. It was just a kid who liked cars.”
“They've cuffed him, bound his feet with duct tape, and stuffed his mouth with a handkerchief. Still, despite all their precautions, they had to knock him out because he was making such a racket, yelling and banging his feet against the inside of the trunk.”
Host
New York Police Department
organization
Anthony Gaspipe Casso
person
Burton Kaplan
person
Stephen Caracapa
person
Louis Eppolito
person
Jimmy Heidel
person
Lucchese crime family
organization
Gambino crime family
organization
Nicky Guido
person
Audible
organization
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime