#271 - Don't @ Us: Our Unpopular Horror Opinions

Bloody Disgusting Podcast1h 7mMay 6, 2026

Get the full intelligence

Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “#271 - Don't @ Us: Our Unpopular Horror Opinions” inside PodZeus.

AI-Generated Summary

In this lively and candid episode of the Bloody Disgusting Podcast, hosts Shelby and Zena dive into their 'unpopular horror opinions'—a fun, self-aware departure from their usual celebration of genre films. They begin with a playful 'would you rather' question about eating used Band-Aids versus having permanent Cheeto fingers, setting a tone of absurd humor before launching into their main topic. The hosts share personal, often surprising takes: Shelby admits she didn’t connect with Ari Aster’s *Midsommar* or *Hereditary*, despite their acclaim, criticizing the protagonist’s choices and the films’ overwhelming sadness. Zena expresses her deep dislike for *The Taking of Deborah Logan*, calling it boring despite its cult status. They then deliver a passionate PSA against the culture of negativity in horror fandom—specifically targeting those who aggressively hate Rob Zombie’s films and then rush to post their disdain online. Both hosts argue that consuming endless criticism drains joy and mental health, advocating instead for celebrating what we love. They also critique the overuse of grief as a metaphor in horror, longing for stories where ghosts are just ghosts, not symbolic of trauma. Finally, they express frustration with social media users who act as if they’ve discovered a 'hidden gem' years after it was widely discussed. The episode ends on a positive note as they enthusiastically recommend *Hokum* and *The Mummy*, praising their originality and visceral impact. The overall tone is self-aware, humorous, and ultimately uplifting—celebrating fandom while calling out its toxic extremes.

Key Takeaways
1

Don’t feel obligated to love every critically acclaimed horror film—your personal reaction matters more than consensus.

2

Negativity in online fandom can be exhausting; consider muting or blocking those who only share criticism.

3

Grief as a horror metaphor is overused—sometimes, a ghost should just be a ghost.

4

Support creators you love by celebrating their work, not just tearing down others’.

5

Revisit older films with fresh eyes, but don’t act like you’re the first to discover them.

Chapters
0:00
2 min

Sponsor: Obsession – A Nightmarish Big Screen Event

The episode opens with a promotional segment for the horror film *Obsession*, directed by Curry Barker, highlighting its 96% Rotten Tomatoes score and intense, blood-soaked atmosphere. The ad positions it as the horror movie of the year, set for release on May 15th.

1:40
2 min

Sponsor: Corporate Retreat – A Gory Team-Building Nightmare

A second sponsor spot promotes *Corporate Retreat*, a horror-comedy about executives trapped in a deadly retreat led by Alan Ruck. The film blends satire with visceral horror, featuring a star-studded cast and special effects by Gary J. Tunnicliffe.

3:20
2 min

Would You Rather: Band-Aids vs. Cheeto Fingers

I can't have Cheeto fingers forever. How do you go like, hello? Nice to meet you. I'm Shelby. Oh, sorry about that. Those are my perpetual Cheeto fingers.

Highlight
5:00
3 min

Unpopular Opinion #1: Midsommar & Hereditary

Both of them made me very sad. Like every bit of them was sad. Everyone was sad. And like I keep using the same word sad. But that's what they say to me is sad.

Highlight
8:20
3 min

Unpopular Opinion #2: The Taking of Deborah Logan

I was so bored with that movie and I was shocked and I've got to say, and I get it. Nobody has to agree with me.

Highlight
High-Impact Quotes
Don't stream it. Close the tab. Walk out of the room. Do it for yourself, for your mental health. But honestly, please, for the love of God. Do it for the rest of us because we're tired.
Zena30:56
Viral: 90.0
It's like why are we even pretending? Like why did we even need to keep following their private lives then? Why didn't we just kind of put that aside a little bit?
Shelby55:19
Viral: 88.0
I want it to just be a ghost. I want it to be a dead person who's haunting a house and not grief as a metaphor.
Shelby39:04
Viral: 85.0
Speakers

Hosts

ShelbyZena
Topics Discussed
Unpopular Horror Opinions95%Grief as a Horror Metaphor90%Online Fandom Culture88%The Conjuring Franchise85%Movie Recommendations80%Found Footage Horror75%Horror Fan Community72%Rob Zombie's Films70%
People & Brands

Midsommar

media

12xNegative

Hereditary

media

11xNegative

Hokum

media

8xPositive

The Taking of Deborah Logan

media

7xNegative

Ari Aster

person

6xNeutral

Rob Zombie

person

6xNeutral

Damien McCarthy

person

5xPositive

Obsession

media

5xPositive

The Mummy

media

5xPositive

TikTok

other

5xNeutral

Get the full intelligence

Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “#271 - Don't @ Us: Our Unpopular Horror Opinions” inside PodZeus.

Start discovering podcast insights today

Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.

No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime