The top five Windward Islands cricketers of all time
The Caribbean Cricket Podcast dives into a fiercely debated ranking: the top five Windward Islands cricketers of all time. Host Marshall St. Patrick acknowledges the region's underrepresentation in West Indies cricket history, noting that no Windward Island batter has ever averaged over 40 in Test cricket—a stark statistic that underscores the challenge of building a legacy in a system historically dominated by larger islands. Despite this, he constructs a list that balances raw stats with cultural impact, placing Darren Sammy at number one not for his numbers (averaging just 21 in Tests), but for his historic leadership: captain of the West Indies to two T20 World Cup titles and the only St. Lucian to lead the team. The list includes Irving Shillingford (5th), Devin Smith (4th) with nearly 15,000 first-class runs, Winston Davis (3rd) with 608 first-class wickets, and Norbert Phillip (2nd), a formidable all-rounder whose career was hampered by the West Indies' golden era. The episode becomes a meditation on legacy: in a region often overlooked, cultural cachet can outweigh statistics. St. Patrick openly invites criticism, admitting his list is subjective and fueled by the emotional weight of representation, not just performance. This isn’t just a ranking—it’s a statement about identity, resilience, and the power of visibility in a sport where geography still shapes destiny.
Darren Sammy is ranked #1 not for stats but for cultural impact: he’s the only St. Lucian to captain the West Indies and led them to two T20 World Cup titles.
No Windward Island batter has ever averaged over 40 in Test cricket, highlighting the region’s historical underrepresentation at the highest level.
Devin Smith’s 14,854 first-class runs are legendary, but his 24 Test average prevents him from topping the list despite his domestic dominance.
Winston Davis and Norbert Phillip are ranked in the top three despite limited Test appearances—proof that first-class excellence can still earn top-tier recognition.
Cultural cachet outweighs pure statistics in the Windward Islands list: legacy, leadership, and regional pride matter as much as averages and wickets.
…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus
Introduction to the Windward Islands Cricketers Series
Host Marshall St. Patrick introduces the second episode in a series ranking top cricketers from each Caribbean territory, focusing on the Windward Islands. He sets the stage by referencing the previous episode on Jamaica and invites audience engagement.
Dave Ingram's All-Time Windward Islands First-Class XI
The host presents a first-class team compiled by fan Dave Ingram, featuring players like Devin Smith, Irving Shillingford, Darren Sammy, and Norbert Phillip. The team is analyzed for its composition and statistical foundation.
The Statistical Reality: Windward Islands' Test Cricket Gap
“There has never been a batter from the Windward Islands that has played for the West Indies that has averaged over 40.”
Number Five: Irving Shillingford – The Victim of His Era
Irving Shillingford, a Dominican cricketer with 92 first-class matches and 37 average, is ranked fifth. The host emphasizes that his career coincided with the West Indies' golden era, limiting his Test opportunities.
Number Four: Devin Smith – The Domestic King
Devin Smith, with 14,854 first-class runs and 19,000 combined runs, is ranked fourth. Despite his dominance, his 24 Test average prevents him from being #1, highlighting the gap between domestic and international success.
“there has never been a batter from the Wynwood Islands that has played for the West Indies that has averaged over 40.”
“four test matches West Indies? Unlikely. The person the Wynwood Islands and people in the region will remember will be Darren Sammy because at the end of the day he was an exceptional captain and has world titles on his resume.”
“I'm not saying I'm right, people. I'm willing for this list to be completely torn apart from Wynwood Island cricket aficionados and even from West Indian cricket historians and even those who are a bit more casual.”
Host
West Indies
other
Windward Islands
other
Marshall St. Patrick
person
Caribbean Cricket Podcast
organization
Darren Sammy
person
Irving Shillingford
person
Devin Smith
person
Winston Davis
person
Dave Ingram
person
Norbert Phillip
person
Is Roston Chase's time up?
34m • 6/8/2026
Caribbean Cricket Podcast 2025 awards: West Indies downbad moment of the year
20m • 6/14/2026
The top five Barbados cricketers of all time
35m • 6/4/2026
The top five Jamaican cricketers of all time
32m • 5/30/2026
Is West Indies cricket economically viable?
43m • 6/7/2026
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime