Thomas Hertog on the Origin of Time
Thomas Hertog, former collaborator of Stephen Hawking, presents a radical rethinking of the universe's origin in his book *The Origin of Time*, arguing that the laws of physics—and even time itself—emerged not from a fixed beginning but through a quantum evolutionary process. Challenging both the multiverse and the idea of a preordained mathematical universe, Hertog proposes a 'no boundary' hypothesis where the Big Bang is not a singularity but a smooth, timeless state akin to the South Pole of a sphere. Drawing on holography and quantum cosmology, he claims that our present observations retroactively select the past, making the universe's history contingent on what we observe today. This top-down, retrocausal framework replaces the anthropic principle with a Darwinian-like evolution of physical laws, where the universe is not designed but discovered through observation. Hertog argues this approach is not only more coherent but also more scientifically rigorous than infinite multiverse models that cannot make testable predictions. The episode dismantles the conventional wisdom of cosmology, revealing how the multiverse—celebrated as a solution to fine-tuning—actually undermines scientific predictability due to the 'measure problem.' Hertog shows that Hawking’s final theory, far from being a triumph of determinism, is a profound shift toward epistemic humility: we don’t have a foundation, only a contingent, observation-dependent reality.
The laws of physics are not fixed at the beginning of time but emerge from a quantum evolutionary process, not a pre-existing blueprint.
The 'no boundary' hypothesis replaces the Big Bang singularity with a smooth, timeless state where time becomes space, akin to the South Pole of a sphere.
Our present observations retroactively select the past history of the universe, making the past contingent on the present—a form of quantum retrocausality.
The multiverse fails as a scientific theory because it cannot make unambiguous predictions; the 'measure problem' renders it observationally useless.
Holography in quantum cosmology explains how the past and laws of physics emerge from a two-dimensional boundary, with time appearing only as information becomes available.
…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus
Introducing the Book and the Core Challenge
“I can already disclose is a variation of on the origin of species of Darwin's.”
The Problem with the Multiverse
Hertog critiques the multiverse as a scientifically unsound explanation for fine-tuning. He argues that the multiverse fails the test of predictability due to the 'measure problem'—there’s no way to assign probabilities to different universes, making predictions ambiguous and thus unscientific.
The No Boundary Hypothesis: A Quantum Origin of Time
“If you trace back the expansion of the universe... you lose the time dimension. The normal time evolution sort of evaporates and turns into a space dimension.”
From Black Holes to the Big Bang: A Theoretical Bridge
Hertog draws a parallel between black hole physics and cosmology. Hawking’s discovery that black holes have entropy and emit radiation led him to develop a time-free, spatial calculation. This same method was applied to the universe, leading to the no boundary idea.
The Retrocausal Revolution: Past Contingent on Present
“The past is contingent on the present. Yes. Yes. Go ahead.”
“We don't have a foundation. In fact, we sort of our hypothesis certainly the holographic formulation of it in which the history and the laws and everything in the past are fundamentally emergent.”
“The laws of physics from that holographic viewpoint don't reach further back. And that is the crucial sort of Darwinian idea.”
“I can already disclose is a variation of on the origin of species of Darwin's.”
Host
Guest
Stephen Hawking
person
Thomas Hertog
person
Andrei Linde
person
Robert Lawrence Kuhn
person
holography
other
cosmic microwave background
other
inflation
other
Alan Guth
person
black hole singularity
other
string theory
other
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime