The Slenderman Stabbing | CreepCast
The real horror behind the Slender Man stabbing wasn’t a fictional monster—it was a system that failed two 12-year-old girls who were screaming for help in silence. Morgan Gazer, diagnosed with schizophrenia and experiencing hallucinations of a figure she called 'It,' was not just influenced by internet lore—she was living inside a delusion so real it overrode her moral compass. Her best friend Anissa Weir, emotionally isolated and struggling with a learning disability, didn’t hallucinate but became a willing participant through a dangerous psychological bond known as folie à deux, absorbing Morgan’s delusions as truth. Together, they planned a ritualistic murder using code words like 'crackers' for knives and 'itch' for killing, culminating in a 19-stab attack in a Wisconsin park. What defies medical logic is that the victim, Peyton Lutner, survived—crawling over a mile through dense forest to find help, a testament to human resilience. The case exposed how untreated mental illness, online escapism, and systemic neglect converged into tragedy, yet the story takes a haunting turn: Peyton forgave her attackers, pursued a medical career, and now uses her trauma to help others. This isn’t just a tale of horror—it’s a wake-up call about the lethal consequences of isolation, the dangers of unchecked online communities, and the fragile line between fantasy and reality when no one is watching.
Morgan Gazer had schizophrenia and experienced real hallucinations of a figure called 'It,' which she believed was Slender Man.
Anissa Weir did not hallucinate but developed folie à deux, adopting Morgan’s delusions as a coping mechanism for social isolation.
The girls used coded language like 'crackers' for knives and 'itch' for killing, showing how deeply they internalized Slender Man lore.
Peyton Lutner survived 19 stab wounds and crawled over a mile through the forest to find help—a physical and psychological miracle.
Peyton forgave her attackers, credited the trauma with giving her life purpose, and now works in medicine to help others.
…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus
Introducing Creep Crime: A New Format
The hosts introduce a new episode format called 'Creep Crime,' blending true crime with horror storytelling. They announce the focus on the real-life Slender Man stabbing that occurred on May 31, 2014, and emphasize the episode's goal: to explore a real tragedy rooted in internet culture while honoring the survivor's resilience.
The Lutner Family and the Two Friends
The episode sets the scene in Waukesha, Wisconsin, introducing Peyton Lutner and her best friend Morgan Gazer. Peyton is portrayed as a typical 12-year-old, while Morgan begins to show signs of severe mental illness, including hallucinations and self-harm, which go unaddressed by her family and school.
Morgan’s Mental Health and the Origins of Her Delusions
The hosts delve into Morgan’s history of hallucinations, including a ghost that bit her as a child, a voice named Maggie, and a figure named Sev she believed was real. Her father, Matt, also had schizophrenia and refused medication, normalizing delusions in the household.
Anissa Weir: A Friend in Need, a Partner in Crime
Anissa Weir, a lonely girl with a learning disability, becomes Morgan’s only friend. The two bond over online creepypasta forums, where they discover Slender Man. Anissa begins to adopt Morgan’s delusions, not because she sees visions, but because she craves connection.
The Birth of the Slender Man Myth and Its Real-World Consequences
The hosts explain how Slender Man originated as a Photoshop contest image in 2009 and evolved into a global online phenomenon. The girls became obsessed, interpreting the lore as real and believing they had to become 'proxies' to survive.
“Get out before something bad happens to you. Even if you're guilted into it.”
“It's like fucking getting struck by lightning or something. It's just like the perfect storm to hit this.”
“I hate you! I trusted you! I can't see! Echoed out into the air as Anissa stood by and watched, egging on her best friend to continue the bloodbath.”
Hosts
Slender Man
other
Peyton
person
Peyton Lutner
person
Morgan
person
Morgan Gazer
person
Anissa
person
Anissa Weir
person
Matt Gazer
person
Winnebago Mental Health Institute
organization
Slenderman stabbing
other
704: "Not Tomorrow Yet" (TWD S6E12 Rewatch)
1h 33m • 6/1/2026
Over The Line 5.29.26
1h 28m • 6/2/2026
How to Potluck Your Way to a Union
43m • 6/2/2026
TELL ME SOMETHING GOOD (TUES): Amy’s Feel-Good Mom Moment
29m • 6/2/2026
FULL SHOW: Megan Thee Stallion Teases New Song Snippet & Takes Aim At Her Ex-Boyfriend, Klay Thompson + Jeezy Interview
1h 40m • 6/3/2026
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime