From Protecting Michelle Obama to Building a Family Through Surrogacy: LGBTQ+ Advocate Cory Allen on Love, Loss and Fatherhood

Infertile AF: Infertility and Modern Family Building through ART35mJune 13, 2026
AI-Generated Summary

Corey Allen, a former U.S. Secret Service agent who protected Michelle Obama, shares his raw and inspiring journey from protecting national icons to becoming a father through surrogacy—a path marked by profound loss, emotional vulnerability, and unwavering love. His story reveals the hidden emotional toll of surrogacy: the heartbreak of two failed embryo transfers, the trauma of losing two pregnancies, and the grief that lingers long after the medical process ends. What makes his narrative revolutionary is not just his resilience, but his insistence that men in LGBTQ+ families must be allowed to grieve openly, to cry, and to be emotionally present—challenging the myth that strength means silence. He also exposes the industry’s misleading 'rosy picture' of surrogacy, warning that success is never guaranteed and that emotional and financial preparedness are non-negotiable. Through his children’s book *Dada Takes a Trip*, Corey turns personal pain into a tool for healing, helping young children understand separation and love. His message is clear: building a family through assisted reproduction is not a linear path, but one that demands courage, community, and radical honesty.

Key Takeaways
1

Surrogacy is not a guaranteed path to parenthood—Corey experienced two failed transfers and two miscarriages, proving that loss is a common, valid part of the journey.

2

Men in LGBTQ+ families must be allowed to grieve and express vulnerability—Corey says emotional openness is not weakness, but a necessary part of fatherhood.

3

The surrogacy industry often paints a misleadingly rosy picture; Corey warns that costs, timelines, and success rates are rarely as simple as advertised.

4

Prepare emotionally and logistically before starting surrogacy—Corey emphasizes the need for a strong support network and mental health resources.

5

Involve your child in the process early: Corey talks to his 22-month-old son about his baby sister, helping him prepare for the role of big brother.

…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus

Chapters
0:00
3 min

Welcome to the Show & Sponsor Intro

Allie introduces the episode, welcomes listeners, and shares a sponsor message for Fertil, an FDA-cleared at-home insemination kit, with a discount code for listeners.

1:26
1 min

New Children's Book Project & Pride Month Offer

Allie announces two exciting updates: a chance to be featured in her upcoming book *Petri Dish Princess*, and a $15 sale on her inclusive children's book *Beautiful Bird* for Pride Month.

2:33
1 min

Meet Corey Allen: From Secret Service to Fatherhood

Allie introduces Corey Allen, a former Secret Service agent who protected Michelle Obama, now an author and advocate for LGBTQ+ family building through surrogacy.

3:58
2 min

The Dream of Fatherhood & Early Family Planning

Corey shares that he always wanted to be a dad, inspired by raising his younger sister. He discusses his initial path through adoption, which fell apart when his partner wasn’t ready for kids.

5:43
2 min

The Turning Point: Men Having Babies Conference

Corey and his husband attend the Men Having Babies conference in 2021, which sparks their decision to pursue surrogacy. Corey admits he knew nothing about the process at the time.

High-Impact Quotes
I was just out of embryos that we could use, and nobody prepared us for that letdown, that grief. Because in that window while you're waiting and you get a positive test result, like your mind is like, holy cow, okay, I'm finally going to be a parent.
Cory Allen10:14
And it wasn't until he was born that it hit because we were there with her where Johnny had one leg, I had the other, and she's pushing and Kai's head just popped out.
Cory Allen14:40
So we went to Cheesecake Factory and we're like, let's talk this out. Let's because we just suffered all these losses.
Cory Allen22:01
Speakers

Host

Allie

Guest

Cory Allen
Topics Discussed
surrogacy journey95%LGBTQ plus family building90%emotional grief in fertility88%men having babies85%fatherhood and vulnerability82%children's book for parenting78%IVF and embryo loss75%adoption vs surrogacy70%
People & Brands

Cory Allen

person

12xPositive

Allie

person

8xPositive

Michelle Obama

person

6xNeutral

Dada Takes a Trip

book

5xPositive

Secret Service

organization

5xPositive

Men Having Babies

organization

4xPositive

Beautiful Bird

book

3xPositive

Fertil

brand

3xPositive

Petri Dish Princess

book

3xPositive

Cheesecake Factory

other

2xNeutral

Start discovering podcast insights today

Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.

No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime