MLB CBA FIGHT: The back-and-forth will continue! Buckle up! Why anonymous execs are saying MLB expansion is NOT happening! (Episode 1465 Hour 1)
The podcast dives into the escalating MLB CBA negotiations, dissecting the strategic moves of both the Players Association and MLB owners. Host David P. Sampson argues that Bruce Meyer's media appearances aren't just updates—they're calculated tactics to shape public perception, particularly around the controversial 50-50 revenue split. He exposes the real issue: the definition of 'revenue' in the proposal, which includes escrowed funds and amateur bonuses, making the '50%' figure misleading. The host also debunks the narrative that the Padres' $3.9 billion sale proves reckless spending leads to success, pointing out their massive losses and financial instability. A major revelation is that expansion is not on hold—it's a central leverage tool. Owners claim expansion won't happen until after the CBA, but the real game is delaying the definition of revenue so expansion fees (potentially $10B) can be kept out of player share. The episode reveals that both sides are using PR warfare to pressure each other, while the real negotiations happen behind the scenes. The host warns that every media statement is a distraction from actual bargaining. The deeper takeaway? The CBA fight isn’t about money—it’s about control. The players want the definition of revenue locked in first, so expansion fees are shared. The owners want to delay that definition to keep those fees outside the deal. The real power isn’t in the media blitzes, but in the fine print of how revenue is measured.
The 50-50 revenue split is misleading because owners include escrowed funds and amateur bonuses in their calculations, making the actual player share far less than advertised.
Bruce Meyer’s media appearances are strategic PR moves designed to pressure owners, not signal negotiation progress.
The Padres’ $3.9B sale is not a model for success—despite the value, they lost $100M in payroll and nearly collapsed financially.
Expansion is not delayed—it’s being used as a bargaining chip. Owners are pretending it’s off the table to delay defining revenue and keep $10B in expansion fees out of player share.
The real negotiation isn’t at the table—it’s in the definition of 'revenue' and 'salary cap' terms, which determine who controls the money.
…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus
The CBA Negotiation Game Begins
The episode opens with a breakdown of Bruce Meyer’s media appearance, framing it not as a negotiation update but as a strategic PR move to influence public opinion and pressure owners.
The 50-50 Revenue Split Is a Mirage
“It's not even a real 50%. It's taking billions of dollars off the top before they're proposing to even share any of that in terms of player share.”
The Padres Are Not a Blueprint
“Did he mention the explosion of the reality of the Seidler family having to sell? Because regardless of Peter Seidler dying or not, they ran the team so irresponsibly that it would be a breach of fiduciary duty in nine out of ten circumstances.”
Expansion Is the Real Weapon
“The problem is in baseball, there is no definition of what the revenues are. So if MLB says that they are definitely expanding and they expect $5 billion franchise that's 10 billion dollars of expansion fees that the players will say well wait a minute put that in the pot that gets split with the players”
The PR War Is a Distraction
Sampson argues that the back-and-forth media statements are not progress—they’re time-wasting tactics that divert energy from actual negotiations.
“It's not even a real 50%. It's taking billions of dollars off the top before they're proposing to even share any of that in terms of player share.”
“The problem is in baseball, there is no definition of what the revenues are. We talked about it earlier this hour. So if MLB says that they are definitely expanding and they expect $5 billion franchise that's 10 billion dollars of expansion fees that the players will say well wait a minute put that in the pot that gets split with the players”
“When you are negotiating a collective bargaining agreement, you have to understand the defined terms. You have to bargain and argue the definition of revenue, how it's going to be measured.”
Host
david p. sampson
person
major league baseball
organization
mlb players association
organization
bruce meyer
person
san diego padres
organization
donald trump
person
half man
media
draft kings
organization
miami marlins
organization
aaron nola
person
Hour 1: The Great Studio Flood
37m • 5/30/2026
Hour 2: No Easy Way Out
33m • 5/30/2026
Hour 3: What is an American
34m • 5/30/2026
From the Archive: Charlie’s 2022 YWLS Q&A
38m • 5/30/2026
Ghana passes bill criminalising promotion of LGBTQ rights
26m • 5/30/2026
MLB in May! June predictions! A freak injury I have NEVER seen before! MORE ABS challenge problems!? (Episode 1464 Hour 2)
53m • 6/1/2026
ZASLOW SHOW 2.0 - But Do They Hate To Lose
41m • 6/1/2026
Myles Garrett from "CAREER BROWN" to traded? Will the Bears get a deal done? An Aspiration update! (Episode 1465 Hour 2)
53m • 6/2/2026
ZASLOW SHOW 2.0 - Can Both These Teams Lose | Joe Fortenbaugh Joins
34m • 6/2/2026
Trouble brewing in Boston for Craig Breslow? Aaron Judge and the Yanks need good news! Downtown Dallas losing pro sports!? (Episode 1466 Hour 1)
53m • 6/3/2026
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime

