INSANE Safety Draft Class in 2026: Caleb Downs, Keionte Scott, AJ Haulcy, Jalon Kilgore

In this deep dive on the 2026 NFL Draft's safety class, Brian Peacock and Eric Crocker of Locked On 49ers analyze four top prospects: Caleb Downs, AJ Halsey, Jalen Kilgore, and Keontae Scott. They assess each player's fit for the San Francisco 49ers’ defense, emphasizing the team’s need for versatility and playmakers. Caleb Downs is praised for his elite instincts and run support, but concerns about his size, lack of deep safety reps, and potential knee issues (partially torn meniscus, degenerative ACL flag) raise doubts about a top-10 pick. AJ Halsey is seen as a physically imposing box safety with solid instincts and coverage range, but not a true coverage specialist—comparable to Jaquiski Tartt. Jalen Kilgore, despite athleticism and strength, struggles in coverage, especially in the slot, and appears more reactive than instinctive. Keontae Scott emerges as the standout, drawing strong comparisons to Jimmy Ward for his elite versatility, athleticism, and ability to play multiple roles—nickel, free safety, or man coverage. His pro day numbers (sub-4.4 40-yard dash, 44-inch vertical) and film performance make him a top-tier prospect. The hosts debate whether the 49ers will draft a safety in the first two rounds, concluding it’s unlikely due to their offensive and defensive line priorities, but Scott remains a compelling target in the second or third round. Key takeaways include: 1) Keontae Scott is the most versatile safety in the class and a potential game-changer for defensive flexibility; 2) Caleb Downs’ high ceiling is tempered by injury concerns and limited deep coverage experience; 3) The 49ers may not prioritize safety in the first two rounds, but a second-round pick like Scott could significantly upgrade their defense; 4) The 2026 safety class is exceptionally deep, potentially pushing top-tier players into later rounds; 5) The team’s defensive identity could evolve around a player like Scott who can adapt to multiple schemes. Overall, the episode highlights the growing depth and strategic value of this safety class, with Keontae Scott standing out as the most impactful prospect.