SLEEPERS: Dark Horse Players the Indianapolis Colts Could Take in the 2026 NFL Draft

In this episode of Locked On Colts, hosts Zach Hicks and Jake Arthur continue their deep dive into potential sleeper picks for the Indianapolis Colts in the 2026 NFL Draft, focusing on Day 2 selections (rounds 2–4). They explore six under-the-radar players across defensive tackle, cornerback, and safety positions, emphasizing value, fit, and long-term development over immediate need. The discussion centers on Daryl Jackson Jr., a massive Florida State defensive tackle with elite size and run-stopping potential, as a high-upside third-round option to bolster the interior line. The duo then shifts to cornerbacks, highlighting Keith Abney II from Arizona State for his grit and ball production, VJ Payne from Kansas State as a versatile safety with corner potential, and Will Lee from Texas A&M for his man-coverage experience. They close with Charles Demings from Stephen F. Austin and Hezekiah Massis from Cal, both praised for athleticism and zone coverage IQ, despite physical or consistency concerns. The episode underscores the Colts’ historical preference for defensive backs and their ongoing need to strengthen depth across the secondary. Key takeaways include: 1) Prioritize big, physical defensive tackles with run-stopping ability for long-term value; 2) Look beyond traditional roles—safeties with corner traits can be high-value projects; 3) Man-coverage corners with experience are rare and worth targeting; 4) Ball production and football IQ matter as much as athleticism; 5) The Colts’ draft culture favors defensive backs, so expect continued investment. The tone is optimistic and analytical, with a strong emphasis on player development and strategic value over flashy names.