QB PROSPECTS: Could Ty Simpson or Garrett Nussmeier Have ANY Dynasty Value After NFL Draft?

Locked On Dynasty Football - Daily NFL Dynasty Fantasy Football podcast28mApril 14, 2026

Get the full intelligence

Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “QB PROSPECTS: Could Ty Simpson or Garrett Nussmeier Have ANY Dynasty Value After NFL Draft?” inside PodZeus.

AI-Generated Summary

In this episode of Locked On Dynasty Football, hosts Marcus Mosier and Michael Fabiano dive into the 2026 NFL Draft's quarterback class, focusing on non-Fernando Mendoza prospects Ty Simpson, Garrett Nussmeier, and Drew Aller. They express strong skepticism about the entire class, calling it one of the weakest in recent memory. Ty Simpson is seen as a high-upside, system-dependent project with a ceiling resembling Brock Purdy, but a floor closer to Colt McCoy—best suited for a backup role in a strong offense. Garrett Nussmeier, despite a tough 2025 season and poor athleticism, is viewed as a potential Jimmy Garoppolo or Mike McCarthy-type backup with NFL pedigree from his father, Doug Nussmeier. Drew Aller stands out for his physical tools and arm talent but is deemed highly inconsistent and prone to mistakes, likened to a more athletic Joe Flacco or Zach Mettenberger. The hosts agree that none of these quarterbacks are likely to start in Year 1, and even Mendoza may not make a fantasy impact early. They advise dynasty managers to avoid drafting them early and instead prioritize veteran QBs or trade for depth. The episode concludes with a strong recommendation to join the Everydayer Club for ad-free access and exclusive group chats. Sponsor segments promote Indeed Sponsored Jobs, FanDuel, TurboTax Local, and Ruggia, emphasizing hiring efficiency, sports betting, tax preparation, and performance support. The overall tone is candid and critical, with hosts admitting they lack excitement for any of the prospects, underscoring the depth of the quarterback drought.

Key Takeaways
1

The 2026 quarterback class is among the weakest in years, with no clear top-tier talent outside of Fernando Mendoza.

2

Ty Simpson’s value is highly dependent on system fit; he’s best suited as a backup in a strong offense, with a ceiling like Brock Purdy and a floor like Colt McCoy.

3

Garrett Nussmeier has NFL bloodlines and strong processing skills but lacks athleticism; he’s best viewed as a high-level backup or developmental project.

4

Drew Aller has elite physical tools but is inconsistent and prone to errors; he’s an all-or-nothing prospect with limited immediate fantasy upside.

5

Dynasty managers should avoid drafting any of these quarterbacks in the first two rounds and consider trading for veteran QBs to improve depth.

…and 2 more takeaways available in PodZeus

Chapters
0:00
2 min

Welcome & Introduction to the 2026 QB Draft Class

Hosts Marcus Mosier and Michael Fabiano welcome listeners to the Locked On Dynasty Football podcast and introduce the topic: evaluating non-Fernando Mendoza quarterbacks in the 2026 NFL Draft. They set a critical tone, signaling a lack of excitement for the class.

1:40
8 min

Ty Simpson: High Ceiling, Low Confidence

I think his ceiling is Brock Purdy. I think his floor is probably a little bit of Colt McCoy.

Highlight
10:00
8 min

Garrett Nussmeier: NFL Bloodline, But Limited Athleticism

I think he could be a Jimmy Garoppolo type of quarterback in the NFL.

Highlight
18:20
8 min

Drew Aller: All-or-Nothing Physical Talent

He’s so far away from being good right now that I just wonder what’s going to ever happen.

Highlight
26:40
2 min

Final Verdict & Dynasty Strategy Advice

The hosts conclude that none of the quarterbacks will start in Year 1 and that even Mendoza may not make a fantasy impact early. They advise dynasty managers to avoid the class, trade for veteran QBs, and prioritize depth. The episode ends with sponsor plugs and a call to join the Everydayer Club.

High-Impact Quotes
Mike McCarthy is a liar.
Marcus Mosier19:33
Viral: 85.0
He’s so far away from being good right now that I just wonder what’s going to ever happen.
Marcus Mosier24:18
Viral: 80.0
I think his ceiling is Brock Purdy. I think his floor is probably a little bit of Colt McCoy.
Marcus Mosier7:36
Viral: 75.0
Speakers

Hosts

Marcus MosierMichael Fabiano
Topics Discussed
2026 NFL Draft Quarterback Class95%Dynasty Fantasy Football Strategy90%Quarterback Development & System Fit85%Backup Quarterback Value80%NFL Draft Projections75%Quarterback Athleticism and Mobility70%NFL Bloodlines and Coaching Influence65%Fantasy Football Draft Timing60%
People & Brands

Ty Simpson

person

25xMixed

Garrett Nussmeier

person

20xMixed

Drew Aller

person

15xMixed

Fernando Mendoza

person

12xNeutral

Brock Purdy

person

8xPositive

Arizona Cardinals

other

8xNeutral

Pittsburgh Steelers

other

7xNeutral

Kirk Cousins

person

6xPositive

Mike McCarthy

person

6xNegative

New York Jets

other

6xNegative

Get the full intelligence

Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “QB PROSPECTS: Could Ty Simpson or Garrett Nussmeier Have ANY Dynasty Value After NFL Draft?” inside PodZeus.

Start discovering podcast insights today

Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.

No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime