290-Unit Avaya Steeplechase In Houston, TX With Shane Thomas, Apartment Syndicator
Shane Thomas, founder of Catalyst Equity Partners, reveals how his team navigated a near-catastrophic refinancing crisis on a 290-unit Class B multifamily property in Houston—originally acquired in 2021 with a bridge loan and aggressive value-add plan. Despite raising NOI from $1.5M to $2M, soaring insurance, tax hikes, and a collapsing rental market forced them to pause renovations after only 140 units. Instead of selling at a loss or defaulting, they executed a bold cash-in refinance using a HUD loan—securing a 35-year fixed-rate mortgage at 4.9%—after committing to the 9–12 month process over a year in advance. The move protected equity, eliminated refinancing risk, and allowed them to focus on operations. Crucially, they achieved an 87% capital call participation rate by structuring the new capital with a preferred return and prioritizing new investors, while demonstrating skin in the game through personal cash injections. Shane admits he would’ve bought a longer-duration rate cap in 2021—when it cost just $80k—instead of a two-year, 1% strike cap that later cost $850k to extend. His key lesson: match your financing tools to your business plan’s timeline, not just the market’s mood. The episode dismantles the myth that bridge loans are inherently risky, arguing they’re a legitimate tool when paired with proper duration and contingency planning.
Secure a HUD loan 9–12 months before maturity to lock in 35-year fixed financing and eliminate refinancing risk.
Structure capital calls with a preferred return and priority for new money to incentivize participation.
Match debt duration to your hold period—avoid 12-year fixed loans if you plan to sell in 5 years due to prepayment penalties.
Buy long-duration rate caps early—$80k in 2021 for a 5-year, 1% strike was a bargain compared to $850k in 2023.
Use bridge loans only for value-add deals with clear exit paths; avoid them for stabilized assets.
…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus
Welcome to Multifamily Investor Nation
Introduction to the podcast and its mission: connecting active and passive multifamily investors through real deal insights from syndicators who close transactions.
Shane Thomas: From CPA to Multifamily Syndicator
Shane shares his background as a former CPA and management consultant who pivoted to multifamily real estate in 2015, co-founding Catalyst Equity Partners to focus on value-add deals across Texas.
Avia Steeplechase: The Original Value-Add Plan
The property was acquired in September 2021 for a 4.9% cap rate. The business plan included $150–200 rent bumps via $10k–12k unit renovations and adding washer-dryer connections for $75/month fees.
The Market Shift: Insurance, Taxes, and Rent Stagnation
“We went from like, I think it was like 600 a door to 1200 a door, right? And over 290 units. That's a huge impact.”
The Pause: Renovations Halted, Market Not Favorable
After completing renovations on only 140 of 220 planned units, the team paused due to poor ROI and a weak rental market, forcing a reevaluation of the exit strategy.
“This is my first HUD loan but we made a decision even though we had plan A and B going, we made a decision in 2024 to invest or commit some money to the HUD process because it takes you know nine months to 12 months to get HUD loan closed, right?”
“And when I had to go buy it in year three, in 2023, end of 23, for a 2 strike, it was $850 ,000, right?”
“In real estate, I think the key is you'd rather have more runway time and liquidity than not.”
Host
Guest
Shane Thomas
person
Avia Steeplechase
other
Catalyst Equity Partners
organization
HUD
organization
PassiveInvesting.com
product
MFINcon.com
product
Harris County
place
RehabWallet.com
product
Alex Rodriguez
person
Dr. Robert Cialdini
person
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime

