Alex Law, "The Roots of Sociology: Scottish Enlightenment and the Civilising Process" (Routledge, 2026)

New Books in Political Science1h 34mJune 2, 2026
AI-Generated Summary

The Scottish Enlightenment wasn't just a collection of philosophical musings—it was a deliberate, elite-driven project to understand and stabilize the emerging commercial society, long before sociology existed as a formal discipline. In 'The Roots of Sociology,' Alex Law argues that thinkers like Adam Smith and Adam Ferguson were not radical revolutionaries but intellectual architects of social order, deeply concerned with the 'civilising process'—the gradual internalisation of self-restraint, the monopolisation of violence by the state, and the formation of civil society. Far from being mere precursors to modern sociology, Law shows they were engaged in a sophisticated, historically grounded analysis of social dynamics, using relational, processual models that anticipated Norbert Elias’s later work. The book challenges the presentist bias in contemporary sociology, urging the discipline to recover its historical self-awareness and to embrace a broader, more integrative vision—one that includes utopian thinking, historical depth, and a critical engagement with power, patronage, and the unintended consequences of social change. This isn’t nostalgia; it’s a call to reclaim sociology’s intellectual roots as a foundation for its future.

Key Takeaways
1

Sociology began not with subaltern movements but with elite intellectuals seeking to understand and stabilize commercial society through the civilising process.

2

The Scottish Enlightenment thinkers were pre-sociologists who developed relational, processual models of social change long before sociology existed.

3

The civilising process, as theorized by Elias, was not about moral progress but about the state's monopoly on violence and the internalisation of self-restraint.

4

The Scottish Enlightenment was shaped by the violent state formation process in Scotland, including the suppression of Highland clans and the Jacobite rebellions.

5

Intellectuals of the Scottish Enlightenment operated as a 'double-facing strata,' balancing patronage networks with internal intellectual rivalry and dialogue.

…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus

Chapters
0:00
1 min

Princeton University Press Spring Sale

A promotional segment for Princeton University Press's 50% off spring sale, encouraging listeners to visit press.princeton.edu and use code SPRING50.

0:58
0 min

Introduction to Alex Law and the Book

Host Matt Dawson introduces Alex Law, Professor of Sociology at Abatei University, and the new book 'The Roots of Sociology: Scottish Enlightenment and the Civilising Process'.

1:27
2 min

The Three Puzzles Behind the Book

I want to recover that historical sociology is very marginal to the discipline at the moment.

Highlight
3:40
1 min

The Civilising Process: Beyond Politeness

The civilising process reshapes what we in sociology call the habitus of people. The personality, in other words, where people over time, first of all among the European upper classes, develop a kind of semi-automatic self-regulation.

Highlight
6:06
1 min

Sociology’s Roots: Not from Subaltern Movements

Sociology sprang not from subaltern social movements demanding social justice but from the struggles of intellectual elites to understand and categorize precisely how social processes and consequences transcend the wishes and actions of individual social agents.

Highlight
High-Impact Quotes
But here I describe this as the violence to annul violence. It's a pacification process. It's a pacification process conducted by the centralized state in order to secure for itself the monopoly over the means and the internal means of violence.
Alex Law51:27
Sociology sprang not from subaltern social movements demanding social justice but from the struggles of intellectual elites to understand and categorize precisely how social processes and consequences transcend the wishes and actions of individual social agents.
Alex Law13:05
So the civilising process reshapes what we in sociology call the habitus of people. The personality, in other words, where people... over time, first of all among the European upper classes develop a kind of semi-automatic self-regulation
Alex Law10:06

Start discovering podcast insights today

Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.

No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime