Full Episode: Saints Would You Rather: Is moving up or down worth the price?
Get the full intelligence
Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “Full Episode: Saints Would You Rather: Is moving up or down worth the price?” inside PodZeus.
In this episode of NewOrleans.Football, hosts dive into the Saints' offseason preparations ahead of the upcoming NFL Draft, focusing on roster evaluation, draft strategy, and team-building decisions. The discussion kicks off with a 'Would You Rather' segment centered on whether the Saints should trade up or down in the draft, analyzing the cost and value of moving from pick 8 to 5 or trading down to 14. The hosts debate the trade math using updated draft value charts, emphasizing the importance of realistic valuation over outdated models like the Jimmy Johnson chart. They express skepticism about trading up for pass rushers like Ruben Bain or Bailey, citing uncertainty about their ceiling and fit, while showing stronger interest in trading down to accumulate additional picks. The conversation then shifts to key players to watch during OTAs, with Tyler Shuck, A-Chan (Travis Kelce), and Kool-Aid McKinstry highlighted as top prospects. The hosts also reflect on Alvin Kamara’s status, noting the uncertainty around his return and the potential significance of his presence at OTAs. Later segments explore fun topics like team-building activities, the future of AI in media, and space-themed movies, ending with a fantasy football question about the best wide receiver in the draft class. The episode blends strategic analysis with lighthearted banter, reflecting both the excitement and complexity of the Saints' offseason.
Trading up for a pass rusher at pick 5 would require giving up a third-round pick, but the hosts are hesitant due to uncertainty about the player's ceiling and fit.
Trading down to pick 14 could yield two additional draft picks, offering more flexibility and depth, which the hosts prefer over trading up.
Tyler Shuck is a key player to watch in OTAs, with expectations for him to emerge as a true leader and number-two receiver.
Alvin Kamara's potential return to OTAs would signal a major shift in the Saints' offseason narrative and could indicate a resolution to his contract situation.
The Saints may benefit more from accumulating picks than making a high-risk move for a single player, especially with multiple roster needs.
Welcome & Upcoming Events
The hosts kick off the episode with announcements for upcoming events, including the draft extravaganza at Loft 18 on April 21st, and promote local sponsors like Matt Bowers for car purchases and PJ's Coffee for morning routines.
OTAs & Key Players to Watch
“I want to see what he looks like on the practice field every day. I want to see Tyler Shuck have one of those practices where he targets him six times and see, is this a go-to guy?”
Draft Strategy: Trade Up vs. Trade Down
“I don't know that I've done too many mock drafts and I, and I've maybe fallen in love with too many players to move. I think I just like, I think I just like my options there.”
Roster Needs & Player Evaluation
The hosts assess the Saints' roster gaps, particularly at pass rush, running back, and receiver. They discuss the potential of players like Caleb Downs, Sonny Styles, and Makai Lemon, and question whether any single player justifies a trade-up.
Team Culture & Offseason Activities
The hosts speculate on what the Saints’ off-season schedule might include, joking about activities like paintball, fishing, and even a fictional reality show. They reflect on team bonding and the importance of culture in player development.
“I want to see what he looks like on the practice field every day. I want to see Tyler Shuck have one of those practices where he targets him six times and see, is this a go-to guy?”
“If Alvin's at OTAs in May, not only would that be the biggest story of the day, it would make me really excited about what, you know, what's about to transpire there.”
“I think Omar Cooper is the one that you're just, if you're going past the big three and you're like, I'm going all upside here, maybe him.”
Host
Tyler Shuck
person
Alvin Kamara
person
Caleb Downs
person
Ruben Bain
person
Makai Lemon
person
Bailey
person
PJ's Coffee
brand
Omar Cooper
person
Kenyan Sadiq
person
Shaw Bear Insurance
brand
Full Episode: Saints buzz & NFL meeting takeaways: Is this the end for Alvin Kamara?
NewOrleans.Football: Saints Podcast • 42m • 4/1/2026
Full Episode: Saints 7-Round Mock Draft: Build around Shough or load up on defense?
NewOrleans.Football: Saints Podcast • 53m • 4/1/2026
Full Episode: 2017 Saints Re-Draft: No Kamara, Lattimore, Ramczyk or Hendrickson?
NewOrleans.Football: Saints Podcast • 45m • 4/3/2026
Full Edisode: Saints Mock Draft: What happens if New Orleans doubles up on D-Line?
NewOrleans.Football: Saints Podcast • 57m • 4/8/2026
Full Episode: Saints zeroing in on wide receivers ahead of the draft
NewOrleans.Football: Saints Podcast • 40m • 4/10/2026
Get the full intelligence
Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “Full Episode: Saints Would You Rather: Is moving up or down worth the price?” inside PodZeus.
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime
