Johnson on Gavin McKenna at the NHL Combine, if Mike Babcock fits in Edmonton, and Mitch Marner's push for the Conn Smythe

OverDrive18mJune 9, 2026
AI-Generated Summary

Mike Johnson delivers a sharp, candid analysis on the NHL Combine's controversial fitness testing, calling it a 'creepazoid fest' that should be held behind closed doors—yet acknowledges its value in player evaluation. He argues that Gavin McKenna, despite his 5'11" frame, has the work ethic and skill set to thrive as a high-end producer in the NHL, comparing him favorably to Artemi Panarin and suggesting he’ll outperform the Bedard comparison due to better team support. On the Edmonton Oilers' potential hiring of Mike Babcock, Johnson dissects the cultural and organizational risks: while Babcock’s coaching pedigree is undeniable, the franchise lacks the 'desperate club' dynamic that once justified his intense style, and Johnson questions whether he can adapt to modern locker room dynamics. He highlights the unprecedented level of player buy-in—especially from McDavid and Dreblaitl—as a key factor in the speculation. Meanwhile, Johnson makes a bold case that Mitch Marner is already the Conn Smythe Trophy favorite, citing his 7 points in 3 games, elite two-way play, and the psychological freedom of playing alongside less dominant linemates, which has freed him from the burden of being the primary offensive engine. The episode closes with a passionate endorsement of Marner’s historic performance and a reminder that the narrative around him has finally caught up to his sustained excellence.

Key Takeaways
1

Fitness testing at the NHL Combine should be private to protect player dignity and reduce performance anxiety.

2

Gavin McKenna’s 14 pull-ups and work ethic suggest he’s built for NHL success despite his small frame, with Panarin as a realistic comparison.

3

Mike Babcock’s potential return to coaching hinges on whether he can adapt to modern locker room culture—Edmonton may not be the right fit.

4

Player buy-in from McDavid and Dreblaitl is critical to Babcock’s hiring, but the team lacks the desperation that once justified his methods.

5

Mitch Marner is the clear Conn Smythe favorite, with 7 points in 3 games and a mental freedom from being the sole offensive burden.

…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus

Chapters
0:00
2 min

Welcome to Doogie's Butler Cabin

Mike Johnson arrives at the T-Mobile arena press box, joking about the lavish setup and sharing a moment with three-time Stanley Cup champ Patty Maroon, who’s also a golf pro on the trip.

2:10
2 min

Gavin McKenna’s Combine Performance and Potential

I expect him when he gets picked to play and be good. Not perfect, but be good. And he'll be playing with better players. So the Bedard comparison, I would expect him to almost look better than Bedard because he won't be asked to do as much.

Highlight
4:10
2 min

The Problem with Public Fitness Testing

I think it needs to be done behind closed doors. And if you want the result, there's no reason that those guys should be doing that testing in front of people with the sawed-off shirts on.

Highlight
6:30
4 min

Edmonton’s Babcock Hiring Speculation

I don't think Edmonton is in that spot at all. And a team may be good enough that would warrant Mike Babcock to come out of retirement and to do it.

Highlight
10:50
4 min

Mitch Marner’s Case for the Conn Smythe Trophy

I don't think it matters who wins the cup anymore. He's going to win the consmite. Like, even if Carolina comes back and wins it, it's not going to be Taylor Hall or Stankhoven or Freddie. Like, I think it's going to be Mitch Marner no matter what.

Highlight
High-Impact Quotes
I don't think it matters who wins the cup anymore. He's going to win the consmite. Like, even if Carolina comes back and wins it, it's not going to be Taylor Hall or Stankhoven or Freddie. Like, I think it's going to be Mitch Marner no matter what.
Mike Johnson14:21
And I think it needs to be done behind closed doors. And if you want the result, there's no reason that those guys should be doing that testing in front of people with the sawed -off shirts on.
Mike Johnson3:26
And I don't think Edmonton is in that spot at all. And a team may be good enough that would warrant Mike Babcock to come out of retirement and to do it.
Mike Johnson8:00
Speakers

Host

Johnny

Guest

Mike Johnson
Topics Discussed
conn smythe trophy95%mitch marner92%mike babcock90%edmonton oilers88%nhl combine85%gavin mckenna80%player fitness testing75%nfl combine comparison65%
People & Brands

Mitch Marner

person

15xNeutral

Mike Babcock

person

14xNeutral

Mike Johnson

person

12xNeutral

Edmonton Oilers

organization

10xNeutral

Gavin McKenna

person

8xPositive

Carolina Hurricanes

organization

7xNeutral

Toronto Maple Leafs

organization

6xNeutral

Connor McDavid

person

6xPositive

Zach Hyman

person

5xNeutral

Vegas Golden Knights

organization

5xNeutral

Start discovering podcast insights today

Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.

No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime