Yankees Off To Incredible Start Despite Bullpen Concerns | Pinstripe Post
Get the full intelligence
Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “Yankees Off To Incredible Start Despite Bullpen Concerns | Pinstripe Post” inside PodZeus.
The Pinstripe Post episode examines the New York Yankees' strong 7-2 start to the 2026 season, highlighting their offensive dominance—particularly their franchise-record 30 walks in a three-game series—while addressing growing concerns about the bullpen, defensive lapses, and underperforming bottom-of-the-order hitters. Joel Sherman and Ryan Dempster debate whether the early struggles of players like Ryan McMahon, Austin Wells, and Jazz Chisholm are indicative of deeper issues or simply small-sample variance. They emphasize that despite the noise, the Yankees are in a unique window of opportunity with a healthy roster and a weak AL East, urging fans to focus on long-term development over short-term frustrations. The conversation also touches on the Yankees’ strategic patience in evaluating players like Ben Rice and the looming return of key injured stars such as Anthony Volpe and Carlos Rodón, with the team prioritizing peak performance for September and October. The episode concludes with a forward-looking assessment of the bullpen’s volatility and the likelihood of midseason trades to strengthen relief depth.
The Yankees' 7-2 start is historically strong, with a franchise-record 30 walks in a three-game series, signaling offensive dominance.
Despite early struggles, players like Ryan McMahon and Austin Wells are expected to improve with better weather and more at-bats.
Jazz Chisholm’s defensive lapse in a key game highlights the risk of high-impact mistakes in a contract year.
The bullpen, while showing signs of instability, is still being evaluated early—early blips may not reflect long-term performance.
The Yankees are prioritizing player development and roster flexibility, with key players like Volpe and Rodón expected to return in May/June.
…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus
Yankees' Historic Start and Early Season Optimism
“They're beating the teams they should beat. They should beat the A's this week.”
The Bottom of the Order: Real or Unreal Struggles?
The hosts dissect the poor offensive output from the 7th–9th hitters—Ryan McMahon, Austin Wells, and Jose Caballero—weighing whether these struggles are temporary or indicative of deeper issues. They argue that while the offense is underperforming, the lineup still has power and on-base potential.
Jazz Chisholm’s Contract Year and Defensive Lapses
“You're the Yankees. You're supposed to be – like Josh, I mean, you're in a contract year. You have a great, great opportunity... Don't have those type of moments.”
Bullpen Concerns and the Search for Stability
“If Weathers and Carlos LeGrande were their setup guys to Bednar in July, I wouldn't be shocked.”
Long-Term Strategy: Health, Development, and the Road Ahead
The hosts discuss the Yankees’ long-term planning, including the expected return of Volpe and Rodón, the need to evaluate young arms like Weathers, and the importance of building a strong foundation before the trade deadline.
“You're the Yankees. You're supposed to be – like Josh, I mean, you're in a contract year. You have a great, great opportunity... Don't have those type of moments.”
“I think the Yankees have the greatest ambitions. I think they believe the way they get from here to the Canyon of Heroes... is Cole, Schlittler, Fried, Rodan as four going round and round in October also at peak.”
“They're beating the teams they should beat. They should beat the A's this week.”
Host
Guest
New York Yankees
other
Joel Sherman
person
Ryan Dempster
person
Ryan McMahon
person
Jazz Chisholm
person
Austin Wells
person
Jose Caballero
person
Anthony Volpe
person
Ben Rice
person
Jake Bird
person
Get the full intelligence
Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “Yankees Off To Incredible Start Despite Bullpen Concerns | Pinstripe Post” inside PodZeus.
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime