TAA 12 - Hitters Who Caught Our Eye
The hosts of Pitcher List Fantasy Baseball dive deep into four hitters whose performances have defied expectations in 2026, using advanced analytics to separate noise from signal. Gunnar Henderson, once a top-tier fantasy asset, shows alarming signs of decline: a drop in bat speed, a shift to a more aggressive, less disciplined swing, and a collapse in power consistency despite maintaining a solid homer rate. His 90th percentile exit velocity has plummeted, and his process-plus score has fallen to league average—painting a picture of a hitter losing his edge. In stark contrast, Munitaka Murakami is thriving as a high-risk, high-reward power machine, with a 164 homer power plus and elite strikeout management through a smart two-strike approach. His ability to optimize for fly balls and pull rate makes his 32% strikeout rate sustainable. Fernando Tatis Jr. is stuck in a power drought despite elite bat speed and improved contact, likely due to a flatter swing and deeper ball travel that’s killing his pull rate and home run production. Finally, Jordan Walker has unlocked his potential with a loftier swing and better contact quality, turning a once-fragile profile into a legitimate 30-homer, 15-steal threat. The episode reveals that the most sustainable success comes not from isolated stats, but from holistic swing optimization and plate discipline. The key takeaway? In fantasy baseball, regression isn’t just about averages—it’s about the mechanics behind them.
Gunnar Henderson’s bat speed has dropped to 74 mph, down from 76 in 2024, signaling a structural decline in his power profile.
Murakami’s 164 homer power plus is four standard deviations above average—elite, sustainable, and driven by a smart two-strike approach.
Tatis Jr.’s 0 home runs despite elite bat speed are due to a 7-degree attack angle and a 5% drop in pull rate, not lack of talent.
Walker’s 9-degree attack angle and 8% jump in ideal contact rate explain his breakout, not luck or a single swing fix.
A hitter’s process-plus score is more predictive than WRC+—Henderson’s 100 process-plus signals a hollow offensive profile.
…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus
Sponsor: Progressive Auto Insurance
A 60-second ad read for Progressive Insurance, promoting savings of over $900 on average for new customers, with 99% of customers earning at least one discount.
Introducing the Hitters Who Caught Our Eye
The hosts introduce the episode’s focus: four hitters whose 2026 performances have defied expectations—Gunnar Henderson and Fernando Tatis Jr. as underperformers, and Munitaka Murakami and Jordan Walker as breakout stars.
Gunnar Henderson: The Decline of a Power Hitter
“He's not hitting the ball hard enough outside of homers to do a ton of damage and to add a bunch of value there. And he's making poor decisions and not really adding contact value either. So all of those are lining up to, it is kind of an empty calorie homer hitter at this point.”
Munitaka Murakami: The Power Machine
“He's at 164 this year, so you'll note that's four standard deviations, elite, elite player. For context, since 2023, four players have had a homer power plus of 160 or higher.”
Fernando Tatis Jr.: The Power Drought
“He's letting the ball travel deeper. And so the longer your swing is, the more like out in front you'll be. And so generally if you're out in front making contact, that's where pulled contact lives.”
“He's at 164 this year, so you'll note that's four standard deviations, elite, elite player. For context, since 2023, four players have had a homer power plus of 160 or higher.”
“He's not hitting the ball hard enough outside of homers to do a ton of damage and to add a bunch of value there. And he's making poor decisions and not really adding contact value either. So all of those are lining up to, it is kind of an empty calorie homer hitter at this point.”
“Getting out in front is where you pull the ball, that you have to be further into your swing. And so the longer your swing is, the more like out in front you'll be. And so generally if you're out in front making contact, that's where pulled contact lives.”
Hosts
Kyle Bland
person
Nate Schwartz
person
Gunnar Henderson
person
Munitaka Murakami
person
Fernando Tatis Jr.
person
Jordan Walker
person
Petco Park
place
Progressive
organization
StatCast
organization
Chicago White Sox
other
TAA 13 - You Down With IVB? Yeah You Know Me! (with Alex Chamberlain)
1h 12m • 6/3/2026
TWF 151 - The Ultimate Draft Guide to the NCAA Postseason w/ Trevor Powers
1h 11m • 5/30/2026
Daily Fantasy Baseball News and Notes I First Pitch Podcast 5/31/26
10m • 5/31/2026
06/04/26 Hour 2: HOF'er Rob Rains talks Cardinals & why this team plays so relaxed, which player is his surprise star; Aaron Donald back to the Rams?; Draft Winner - Most Hateable Athletes
52m • 6/4/2026
The Shallows EP 017 - Sunken Ships
1h 4m • 6/5/2026
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime