Etay's STOLEN WPT Wynn Poker Trophy Listed For Sale?

PokerNews Podcast34mApril 23, 2026

Get the full intelligence

Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “Etay's STOLEN WPT Wynn Poker Trophy Listed For Sale?” inside PodZeus.

AI-Generated Summary

The PokerNews Podcast kicks off episode 958 with a gripping mystery surrounding Esther Taylor's stolen WPT World Championship trophy, which surfaced on eBay for $600. Host Chad Holloway reveals he discovered the listing and reached out to Taylor, who was unaware her 2022 mixed game trophy had gone missing after a cross-country move. Conflicting stories from the seller—claiming to have found it at a pawn shop versus a Goodwill in Pennsylvania—have raised red flags, suggesting theft. The hosts speculate on a possible broader conspiracy of stolen poker memorabilia, referencing past incidents like Phil Hellmuth’s missing 1989 WSOP bracelet and Chris Moneymaker’s lost Oakley sunglasses. The episode also covers WrestleMania weekend in Las Vegas, including a viral video of Jared Blesnick (TheBless) meeting The Miz and discussing a $1.5 million sports card sale. The hosts reflect on the 15th anniversary of Black Friday, sharing personal stories of how the online poker shutdown reshaped their careers. They highlight recent U.S. Poker Open winners, including Alex and Kristen Foxen, Brock Wilson, and Katerina Lukina, who won a $42K event. Finally, Chad shares his experience at the record-breaking 46th Irish Poker Open, praising its scale, vibrant 'Crack Den' party space, and international ambitions for 2027.

Key Takeaways
1

Investigate any missing poker memorabilia—especially trophies—by checking eBay and contacting sellers directly.

2

Conflicting stories from a seller (pawn shop vs. Goodwill) are a major red flag for potential theft.

3

Black Friday’s legacy continues to shape the careers and perspectives of today’s poker professionals.

4

The Irish Poker Open is a major international event with record turnout and a unique party atmosphere.

5

Supporting poker media professionals who play competitively helps bridge the industry-player divide.

…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus

Chapters
0:00
2 min

Opening: The Stolen WPT Trophy Mystery

Itay is going to keep me in the loop. But I don't know. What should she do in this situation? It's 600 bucks. She could buy it back.

Highlight
2:00
3 min

The eBay Listing and Conflicting Stories

Chad details how he discovered the trophy listing, reached out to the seller claiming to have found it at a pawn shop, and then contacted Esther Taylor—only to learn she had no idea it was missing.

5:00
4 min

Esther Taylor’s Reaction and the Moving Mystery

Esther Taylor confirms she had no idea her trophy was missing, suspects it was taken during a cross-country move, and expresses her desire to recover it without questions.

9:00
3 min

The Broader Conspiracy: Stolen Poker Memorabilia?

The hosts speculate on a possible larger trend of stolen poker memorabilia, referencing past incidents like Hellmuth’s missing bracelet and Moneymaker’s lost sunglasses.

12:00
3 min

WrestleMania Weekend and the $1.5M Sports Card

The team discusses Jared Blesnick meeting The Miz, the shock of a $1.5 million sports card sale, and the cultural significance of such high-value collectibles.

High-Impact Quotes
The Irish Poker Open is going international if you haven't heard. They're going to do stops in Marrakesh, Australia and even the United States in 2027.
Chad Holloway33:37
Viral: 90.0
This turns into a massive story. And then there's like a cat burglar going around robbing very inexpensive pieces of poker memorabilia. That would be dope.
Chad Holloway7:57
Viral: 85.0
I just want the trophy back. It's, you know, whatever. No questions asked.
Esther Taylor6:23
Viral: 80.0
Speakers

Hosts

Chad HollowayBen LudlowMike Holtz

Guests

Esther TaylorJared BlesnickThe MizKaterina LukinaChris ConradBarry CarterBrian MoleskyWill KasuvDom and Chris (Bad Poker Podcast)
Topics Discussed
Stolen Poker Trophy95%Irish Poker Open92%Black Friday Anniversary90%Online Poker History88%U.S. Poker Open Winners85%Poker Memorabilia Culture80%Poker Media and Players78%WrestleMania in Las Vegas75%
People & Brands

Irish Poker Open

other

12xPositive

Chad Holloway

person

12xNeutral

Mike Holtz

person

11xNeutral

Ben Ludlow

person

10xNeutral

Black Friday

other

10xNeutral

U.S. Poker Open

other

8xPositive

Esther Taylor

person

8xNeutral

eBay

product

7xNeutral

WPT World Championship

other

6xNeutral

PokerStars

product

5xNeutral

Get the full intelligence

Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “Etay's STOLEN WPT Wynn Poker Trophy Listed For Sale?” inside PodZeus.

Start discovering podcast insights today

Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.

No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime