Ligaya Mishan & Tejal Rao, The Modern Restaurant Critics Of The New York Times
Ligaya Mishan and Tejal Rao, the co-chief restaurant critics at The New York Times, are redefining restaurant criticism for a new era—one that values inclusivity, authenticity, and the human cost of the job. In a candid conversation with host Carrie Diamond, they reveal how their diverse childhoods—Mishan’s multicultural upbringing in Hawaii, where Spam and luau feasts were daily rituals, and Rao’s global journey through London, Uganda, and India—shaped their deep reverence for food as both cultural expression and daily joy. Their groundbreaking 2026 New York Times 100 Best Restaurants list, which prioritized accessibility and local voices over prestige, was not just a ranking but a portrait of the city’s soul, with Ligaya’s top pick, Cabala, a Caribbean restaurant in the East Village that redefines fine dining with warmth and artistry. They openly discuss the toll of the job—Pete Wells’ health essay made them confront their own limits—and how they’re building boundaries to sustain themselves, from personal trainers to mental resets. Amid the chaos of dining, writing, and public scrutiny, they remain committed to the idea that restaurants are more than places to eat: they’re communal spaces where humanity, creativity, and resilience persist, even in the face of fires, strikes, and AI. Their work is not just criticism—it’s a love letter to the people who keep feeding us, one imperfect, passionate meal at a time.
The New York Times' 100 Best Restaurants list is designed for all New Yorkers, not just the elite—100% of the top spots are accessible for under $25, including taco trucks and double spots.
Ligaya Mishan chose Cabala, a Caribbean restaurant in the East Village, as the top restaurant in NYC because it delivers refined, joyful fine dining that honors its roots without pretense.
Both critics prioritize self-care: Ligaya runs eight miles at noon during her lunch break, and Tejal sets strict travel limits to protect family time and mental health.
They reject the myth of the 'perfect critic'—their job is not about eating endlessly but about deep, intentional engagement with food as culture and craft.
Menu storytelling is evolving: Paper Bridges in Portland uses detailed back-of-menu narratives to educate diners about Northern Vietnamese cuisine, balancing accessibility with depth.
…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus
Introducing the New Voice of Restaurant Criticism
Host Carrie Diamond introduces Ligaya Mishan and Tejal Rao, the co-chief restaurant critics at The New York Times, setting the stage for a conversation about the future of food writing, inclusivity, and the personal cost of the job.
Roots in the Kitchen: Childhoods That Shaped Their Palates
“I just took it for granted that this was how people ate. It's so easy growing up in the mainland to romanticize Hawaii.”
The Chaotic Reality of Being a Critic
“I wish that it was possible to structure it more, but I think because we're bodies and we're not machines. That's the way it has to be.”
The 100 Best List: A Portrait of the City, Not a Ranking
“This is a list for the city. This means that wherever you're coming from, you can go and eat at one of the best places in New York.”
Handling the Heat: Critics, Comments, and Emotional Labor
Both critics admit they have thin skins but are committed to listening—especially when readers share powerful stories about rediscovering beloved neighborhood spots like Hopley in Chinatown.
“I just feel like that's enormously appealing both for the people who are making the food and for the people who are going to the restaurants, you know?”
“This is a list for the city. This means that wherever you're coming from, you can go and eat at one of the best places in New York.”
“You know, I wish that it was possible to structure it more, but I think because we're bodies and we're not machines. That's the way it has to be,”
Host
Guests
Ligaya Mishan
person
Tejal Rao
person
The New York Times
organization
Pete Wells
person
Cherry Bomb
organization
Cabala
other
Paper Bridges
other
Whole Foods Market
organization
Squirrel Restaurant
other
Hopley
other
The Best Weekend Talk Show In America Hour One
37m • 6/1/2026
Platner's "Sexting" Scandal Lies, Jill Biden's Book Tour Panic, and CBS Host Attacks Boss Bari, with Emily Jashinsky | Ep. 1329
1h 59m • 6/1/2026
Strait to the Abyss
1h 0m • 6/2/2026
"Scott Pelley Wanted To Be Fired" — Howie Kurtz Exposes CBS 60 Minutes Drama
15m • 6/6/2026
Rapid Response: The Guardian’s secret weapon against media’s collapse, with CEO Anna Bateson
30m • 6/6/2026
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime

