5 On It: Which Cubs player deserves a toast for his part in win over Phillies?

The episode opens with a lively discussion on the Cubs' 11-2 victory over the Phillies, focusing on which player deserves a toast for their contribution. Hosts Rahimi, Harris, and Gabe Ramirez debate standout performers, with Marshall initially praising Dansby Swanson for his offensive spark and batting average resurgence, while Gabe counters with admiration for starting pitcher Shota Emanaga, highlighting his 11 strikeouts, 26 swings and misses, and dominant 2.45 ERA. The conversation shifts to the Cubs' potential signing of veteran right-hander Lucas Giolito, weighing his past inconsistency against his ability to eat innings and add depth to a rotation strained by injuries. Gabe remains skeptical, citing Giolito’s rocky post-White Sox career, while Marshall argues the Cubs need any reliable arm. The segment then pivots to the White Sox, where Sam Antonacci’s debut is celebrated for injecting energy and defensive grit, despite the team’s overall offensive struggles. The hosts debate the White Sox’s delayed call-up strategy for young talent, acknowledging it as a smart business move for service time. The episode closes with a humorous take on Bears quarterback Caleb Williams’ Instagram post imagining him and three other Chicago athletes on Mount Rushmore, with the hosts agreeing that only Williams has a realistic path—conditional on winning a Super Bowl and sustaining excellence. The conversation ends with a call for listeners to suggest overlooked Chicago sports legends for the Mount Rushmore.