Which players would concern you if the Cowboys took them at 12?

Shan and RJ dive into the latest mock drafts and draft speculation surrounding the Dallas Cowboys' 12th overall pick, focusing on whether top prospects like Caleb Downs and Sonny Stiles will still be available. They react to Peter Schrager's initial mock draft placing Downs at 12, only to retract it the next day, sparking debate over whether Downs could realistically last that long. The hosts explore alternative targets, including Keldrick Falk—a 6'7" defensive lineman rumored to be on the Cowboys' radar but widely unpopular among fans and analysts due to concerns about his pass rush ability and effort. They also examine Mel Kuyper Jr.'s bold mock draft, which envisions the Cowboys trading up from 12 to 6 to select Sonny Stiles, a move that would address their dire defensive needs. The discussion weighs the risks of trading up versus settling for value at 12 or 20, with differing opinions on whether the Cowboys should prioritize elite talent over positional need. The episode underscores the uncertainty of the 2026 draft class, especially with top-tier defensive players expected to go early and the Cowboys' lack of defensive identity in 2025.