The Shadow on the Stairs
A haunted house in upstate New York becomes the epicenter of a lifetime of paranormal phenomena for Carla, whose childhood was marked by inexplicable events that defied rational explanation. From a baby who seemingly vanished and reappeared in her parents' bedroom to a ghost dog brushing against her feet while she watched a ghost-hunting show, the house pulsed with activity that spanned decades. The most chilling moments include a floating cigarette ember in a Cape Cod hotel room and a baby crib mobile playing in an empty room—events witnessed by multiple family members, including her father and dog. Despite the fear, Carla reflects on the eerie sense of presence that wasn't malicious, even suggesting a maternal spirit may have gently returned her to bed. The house, built during the Dutch colonial era and layered with forgotten artifacts like a pipe and a shoe in the walls, seems to hold more than just history—it holds memory. As Carla reveals, the phenomena ceased the moment she left the house, raising the haunting question: was the house haunted, or were its inhabitants tuned to something far older and deeper than they knew? What makes this story stand out is not just the volume of experiences, but their consistency and specificity. Carla’s recollections are precise—times, distances, sensory details like the glow of a cigarette ember or the texture of fur under her feet. These aren’t vague anecdotes; they’re lived moments that shaped her identity.
A baby disappeared from her crib in a locked room, reappeared at the foot of her parents' bed, and was not found in any other location—despite multiple checks by her parents and a sleeping father.
The house had a history of dog deaths, including a fire that killed poodle kennels, and a ghost dog was felt brushing against Carla’s feet while she watched a ghost show.
A floating cigarette ember, glowing with embers, appeared in a hotel doorway during a family trip—visible, close, and unexplained, with no smoke or smell.
The house was built during the Dutch colonial era, and artifacts like a clay pipe and a shoe in the wall were discovered during renovations, suggesting intentional spiritual markers.
Multiple family members experienced the same phenomena, including footsteps heard on the phone, lights appearing on ceilings, and dishes exploding with pinpoint force.
…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus
Welcome to Carla's Haunted House
Rob introduces Carla, a guest whose family experienced a wide range of paranormal phenomena in an old upstate New York house. The episode sets the stage with Carla’s story of a baby disappearing from a crib and reappearing at the foot of her parents' bed.
The Baby Aport: A Vanishing Act
“I'm not in the bassinet. That's strange. Okay, well, the mobile is still playing in the other room. And oh, well, maybe my father put me to bed in there.”
The Father’s Witness: A Rocking Chair and a Dog
Carla’s father recounts hearing a rocking chair move on its own and seeing the dog stare at the ceiling. This corroborates the mother’s story and adds a layer of shared experience, suggesting the event was not a hallucination.
The Ghost Dog: A Furry Presence
“I feel this rush of fur brush underneath the tops of my feet. Wow. Stomach down, feet off the bed. And I feel fur underneath me.”
The Floating Pipe and the Dutch Legacy
“I wonder if he made the connection whether it was my father or whether it was the people who originally built the house and maybe stashed these things in the wall.”
“And all of a sudden, only maybe a minute later, I feel this rush of fur brush underneath the tops of my feet. Wow. Stomach down, feet off the bed. And I feel fur underneath me.”
“And it was small like a cigarette. And it was just in the doorway, just like as if someone was holding it, leaning on the doorway and just watching us.”
“There was no distinctive features, but I look behind me on the couch. My dad's sleeping right there. It watched me all night.”
Hosts
Guest
Carla
person
The Keystone Hagstone
book
Eamon
person
Rob
person
Wes Larson
person
Jeff
person
Mike
person
Travis the Chimpanzee
other
Joe Simonton
person
Walton Goggins
person
Honest Truth About Finding Purpose
16m • 6/1/2026
Lena Waithe
2h 0m • 6/1/2026
972. I Love Hearing Testimonies... But They All Started the Same Way
26m • 6/1/2026
Paris catacombs reopen after renovation
14m • 6/1/2026
Full Show PT 1: Monday, June 1 [Vault]
35m • 6/1/2026
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime

