#529- THE ATLANTA CAMPAIGN (Part the Twenty-seventh)
The Battle of Kennesaw Mountain, a pivotal yet paradoxical moment in Sherman's Atlanta Campaign, stands as a stark contradiction: a Confederate tactical victory that ultimately led to their retreat, and a Union tactical failure that exposed deep strategic tensions. Despite overwhelming odds and devastating casualties, Sherman ordered frontal assaults on June 27, 1864, not out of impatience alone, but driven by a profound fear that Joe Johnston might detach troops to reinforce Robert E. Lee in Virginia—a concern that historian Earl Hess argues was the real engine behind the ill-fated attack. The episode reveals how Sherman, a master of maneuver, was forced into a direct assault only when his strategic options seemed to vanish, highlighting the psychological weight of command under pressure. Yet, the very next day, the Confederates withdrew, proving that the flanking maneuver Sherman had already begun on July 1st would have achieved the same result without bloodshed. This moment underscores a central theme: leadership is not defined by perfection, but by persistence. Within weeks, Sherman would push past Marietta, breach two more defensive lines, and reach the Chattahoochee River—just six miles from Atlanta—demonstrating that failure at Kennesaw was not a dead end, but a detour on a path to ultimate victory.
Sherman’s June 27, 1864, assault at Kennesaw Mountain was driven not by impatience but by fear that Johnston might send troops to reinforce Lee in Virginia.
The Confederate retreat the next day proved a turning maneuver—already underway on July 1—could have achieved the same result without the 4,000 Union casualties.
Historians now agree the Kennesaw assault was a mistake, but Sherman’s ability to press forward despite it defined his leadership more than the failure itself.
The Army of the Cumberland resented being brought in to 'rescue' their own reputation, fueling long-term bitterness toward Sherman and Grant.
Sherman claimed his generals agreed with the attack, but Schofield’s memoirs show they opposed it—highlighting the gap between public narrative and private dissent.
…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus
Introduction: The Atlanta Campaign Returns
The hosts introduce Episode 529, marking the return to the Atlanta Campaign and setting the stage for a deep dive into the Kennesaw Mountain standoff and its aftermath.
Confederate Retreat from Kennesaw Mountain
On July 3, 1864, Union forces discover that Confederate troops have abandoned their Kennesaw lines, prompting celebration among Federals and sorrow over the lives lost in previous assaults.
The Contradictions of Kennesaw Mountain
The battle is framed as a Confederate tactical victory with low casualties, yet a Union strategic success due to the enemy’s retreat—highlighting the paradox of the campaign.
Why Sherman Ordered the Frontal Assault
“It wasn't mere impatience that spurred Sherman to make the momentous decision to attack at Kennesaw, but rather it was worry over what Johnston might do if Sherman didn't completely occupy his attention.”
The Strategic Pressure to Act
Sherman’s concern about Johnston sending reinforcements to Virginia created a sense of urgency, making the attack seem like the only viable option despite its risks.
“And yet William Tecumseh Sherman wasn't defined by his failures. Instead, like his friend Ulysses S. Grant, Sherman was defined by his ability to keep pressing toward his goal, to keep on keeping on.”
“Hess argues that it wasn't mere impatience that spurred Sherman to make the momentous decision to attack at Kennesaw, but rather it was worry over what Johnston might do if Sherman didn't completely occupy his attention.”
“Had General Sherman at this time applied his usual tactics, he would have been spared the bitter regret that he expressed following a futile attempt to break the enemy's fortified lines by assault.”
Hosts
william tecumseh sherman
person
joe johnston
person
george thomas
person
ulysses s. grant
person
henry halleck
person
robert e. lee
person
earl j. hess
person
chickasaw bayou
other
tunnel hill
other
oliver otis howard
person
Bringing Out The Best In Each Other
25m • 5/31/2026
6.8.26 Supreme Court wins for regulators, what’s ahead for graduates, and the establishment of Miranda rights
39m • 6/8/2026
S8 Ep1004: Patrick K. O'Donnell describes how Ulysses S. Grant ordered Phil Sheridan to wage total war in the Shenandoah Valley, commanding the execution of Mosby's men and the destruction of crops. Although Sheridan moderated these orders due to political optics, h
13m • 6/14/2026
S8 Ep1004: Patrick K. O'Donnell highlights Harry Harrison Young, a fearless commander who led the Jesse Scouts as a strategic asset for Phil Sheridan in 1865. Disguised in Confederate uniforms, these scouts provided real-time intelligence and delivered critical mess
13m • 6/14/2026
Episode 377 - Haunted Gettysburg | The Incredible Story of Tillie Pierce House Inn
55m • 6/14/2026
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime

