Haunted Cheney Mansion: From Stagecoach Stop to Spirit Haven, Part Two | Grave Talks CLASSIC
The Cheney Mansion in Jerseyville, Illinois, isn't just a historic estate—it's a living archive of spirits, stories, and supernatural phenomena. Roger Sheffel, the caretaker and paranormal investigator, reveals how the house, once a stagecoach stop and later a grand home of the Cheney family, now pulses with activity. From orbs forming inside mirrors to growls echoing in the drunk room and apparitions appearing in hallways, the mansion delivers tangible, repeatable evidence that challenges skeptics. The most compelling moment? A video of a glowing orb materializing inside a mirror in the music room—captured accidentally during a routine review—so vivid it left Sheffel’s hair standing on end. But beyond the ghosts, the house thrives on legacy: donated artifacts, restored furniture, and a community that honors the past. Sheffel believes spirits aren’t just lingering—they’re playing, interacting, and even approving of the care given to the home. He shares how a psychic once communicated with Judge Darcy, the mansion’s builder, who affirmed his work with a visible reflection in a mirror. The house isn’t haunted in a scary way; it’s alive with joy, mischief, and connection. For visitors, it’s not just a tour—it’s a pilgrimage for history, mystery, and the thrill of the unknown.
A glowing orb formed inside a mirror in the music room and emerged outward—captured on camera, reviewed later, and verified as not dust or debris.
The spirit of Judge Darcy, the mansion’s builder, made physical contact by appearing in a mirror reflection, confirming approval of the caretaking efforts.
Spirits appear to respond to human energy—positive, playful groups often trigger more activity than skeptical or negative ones.
Over 90% of the house’s furnishings are original Cheney family pieces, returned through donations after the 1990s auction.
The house has hosted over 100 paranormal investigations with nearly every group reporting some form of experience.
…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus
The Heart of the Haunting: Surveillance and the Sunroom
Roger Sheffel introduces the surveillance setup at the Cheney Mansion, explaining how 16 cameras cover the house, with the sunroom serving as the central hub for teams. This room is where investigators gather, take breaks, and monitor the entire house in real time.
The Orb That Defied Explanation: A Mirror Manifestation
“It looked like it was formed and came out of the mirror. And that's what it looks like.”
Distinguishing Dust from the Supernatural: The Ghost Hunter’s Eye
Sheffel explains how experienced investigators can differentiate between dust, bugs, and true paranormal orbs. He acknowledges that many false positives come from inexperienced hunters, but insists some phenomena are unmistakably not natural.
The Turning Point: From Skeptic to Believer
“I wasn't until I wasn't. And when I wasn't, it created an animal monster because I've been in love with it ever since.”
The Spirits Are Alive: Fun, Play, and Connection
“I believe these spirits have as much fun with us as we do them.”
“It looked like it was formed and came out of the mirror. And that's what it looks like.”
“Carol, I'll guarantee you I wasn't until I wasn't. And when I wasn't, it created an animal monster because I've been in love with it ever since.”
“And I still right now, if you can see my arms are full of goosebumps and the hair standed straight up.”
Host
Guest
Cheney Mansion
place
PD Cheney
person
Roger Sheffel
person
Judge Darcy
person
Jerseyville
place
Edward Darcy
person
Alton Illinois
place
Ron
person
Mineral Springs Hotel
place
McPike Mansion
place
Haunted Cheney Mansion: From Stagecoach Stop to Spirit Haven, Part One | Grave Talks CLASSIC
35m • 6/12/2026
The Haunted McPike Mansion: Spirits That Won’t Leave, Part Two | Grave Talks CLASSIC
22m • 6/5/2026
Reiki Healing and Communicating with Spirits, Part One | Grave Talks CLASSIC
10m • 6/4/2026
What Really Lives in the Olde Park Hotel? Part One | Grave Talks CLASSIC
47m • 5/30/2026
What Really Lives in the Olde Park Hotel? Part Two | Grave Talks CLASSIC
31m • 5/30/2026
The Man Who Knew Too Much | Real Ghost Stories
26m • 5/30/2026
Woman in Blue Still Waits at Moss Beach Distillery, Part One | Grave Talks CLASSIC
35m • 5/30/2026
Woman in Blue Still Waits at Moss Beach Distillery, Part Two | Grave Talks CLASSIC
19m • 5/30/2026
The Haunting Wasn’t the Creepiest Part of the House | After Midnight
21m • 5/30/2026
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime

