THE HERD - Hour 3 - Tomorrow's Headlines Today, Josh Pate

The Herd with Colin Cowherd32mJune 5, 2026
AI-Generated Summary

Colin Cowherd and guest Josh Pate dive into the evolving landscape of college football, challenging the narrative that superstar player salaries and NIL deals are the root of systemic problems. They argue instead that the real hypocrisy lies in power conferences like the SEC and Big Ten, who once begged Congress for regulatory help to fix college athletics—only to reject a reform bill that would have addressed both governance and revenue. The conversation shifts to Notre Dame’s unique independence, questioning whether their lack of conference affiliation and weak schedule could eventually force them into a conference, especially if they’re left out of a playoff despite a strong record. Cowherd also critiques the Pittsburgh Steelers’ stubborn refusal to shed aging veterans like T.J. Watt, calling their defensive roster 'old and expensive'—a fatal flaw in modern NFL competition. Meanwhile, the duo speculates wildly on NBA offseason drama, including Giannis Antetokounmpo potentially joining the Lakers and LeBron James teaming up with Stephen Curry in a 'Golden State Fossils' reunion. These fantasy scenarios, while absurd on the surface, are grounded in real financial and strategic logic, suggesting that legacy stars may prioritize legacy and legacy-building over pure money in their final years.

Key Takeaways
1

Power conferences like the SEC and Big Ten are hypocritical for demanding congressional help to fix college athletics while rejecting a reform bill that would have addressed both governance and revenue.

2

Notre Dame’s independence could backfire if they’re left out of the playoff due to a weak schedule, forcing them to reconsider joining a conference.

3

The Steelers’ defensive roster is the oldest and most expensive in the NFL, making them vulnerable to injury and slow to adapt—exactly the kind of team that loses in the playoffs.

4

T.J. Watt could be traded for a first-round pick and a second-round pick, just like other elite players such as Miles Garrett and Micah Parsons were, but the Steelers refuse to act.

5

Giannis Antetokounmpo may leave Milwaukee for the Lakers, where he could team up with LeBron James and Luka Doncic in a high-profile, financially feasible 'superteam' reunion.

…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus

Chapters
0:00
2 min

The Hypocrisy of College Football's Power Conferences

The group that cried out that they can't enforce the rules and they just need help and it's not sustainable. Well, this bill fit both of the criteria they were looking for. And they don't like it either because it doesn't fit their interests to a 100 percent T.

Highlight
2:20
4 min

Notre Dame’s Independence and the Risk of Being Left Out

The duo examines Notre Dame’s unique status as an independent program, questioning whether their lack of conference affiliation and weak schedule could lead to them being excluded from the playoff despite a strong record, potentially forcing a structural change.

5:55
4 min

The Value of the College Football Playoff and Schedule Integrity

Cowherd argues that expanding the playoff doesn’t add value—it merely reassigns it to games that are already meaningless, and he stresses the importance of schedule strength in determining playoff eligibility.

10:05
3 min

The Pittsburgh Steelers’ Defensive Crisis

Nothing disqualifies you for a Super Bowl more than old and expensive defense. It's just crazy to me.

Highlight
13:23
5 min

The Kyler Murray vs. J.J. McCarthy QB Situation in Minnesota

The hosts discuss the tension between Kyler Murray and J.J. McCarthy, drawing parallels to past quarterback transitions and questioning how difficult it must be to be a backup when a new star arrives.

High-Impact Quotes
LeBron and Curry together? Two of the best, what, 10, 11 players in the history of the sport? It would be a tremendous... Watch.
Colin Cowherd28:28
Nothing disqualifies you for a Super Bowl more than old and expensive defense. It's just crazy to me.
Colin Cowherd19:09
So all I'm saying is the group that cried out that they can't enforce the rules and they just need help and it's not sustainable. Well, this bill fit both of the criteria they were looking for. And they don't like it either because it doesn't fit their interests to a 100 percent T.
Colin Cowherd4:02
Speakers

Host

Colin Cowherd

Guest

Josh Pate
Topics Discussed
pittsburgh steelers defense92%tj watt trade value90%giannis antetokounmpo free agency88%lebron james golden state reunion85%college football playoff expansion85%notre dame independence80%nba finals predictions75%nfl quarterback competition70%
People & Brands

colin cowherd

person

15xNeutral

notre dame

organization

12xNeutral

pittsburgh steelers

organization

10xNegative

josh pate

person

10xPositive

tj watt

person

8xNeutral

lakers

organization

8xPositive

lebron james

person

7xPositive

j-mac

person

6xNeutral

sec

organization

6xNeutral

giannis antetokounmpo

person

6xPositive

Start discovering podcast insights today

Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.

No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime