405: What if you were accused of murdering your mother?
Get the full intelligence
Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “405: What if you were accused of murdering your mother?” inside PodZeus.
Rachel Waters recounts the harrowing journey of being accused of murdering her mother after her mother's death from advanced Alzheimer's and multiple myeloma. What began as a deeply personal caregiving experience turned into a nightmare when Rachel, a dedicated daughter and advocate, was wrongfully implicated in her mother's death due to the use of a comfort care kit containing morphine. Despite having no criminal intent and acting within medical guidelines, Rachel became a suspect in Columbia County, Georgia, after an anonymous post on Instagram revealed she had been formally charged with felony murder and malice murder—charges that shocked her and triggered a national media frenzy. With the help of a high-profile defense attorney, Brian Steele, Rachel turned herself in and fought for her freedom while gathering overwhelming evidence of her innocence. Her case led to a pivotal change in the official cause of death from 'homicide due to morphine toxicity' to 'undetermined,' and she has since become a passionate advocate for 'Marsha's Law'—a proposed legislation to protect family caregivers by requiring formal documentation and training for the use of controlled substances in end-of-life care. The episode explores the fragility of trust, the emotional toll of wrongful accusation, and the transformative power of community and advocacy in the face of systemic failure.
Family caregivers using comfort care kits for end-of-life pain relief are vulnerable to wrongful criminal charges if proper documentation and training aren't formalized.
The use of morphine in palliative care is not equivalent to euthanasia and should not be misconstrued as a lethal act.
When a loved one is declared actively dying, caregivers must document everything—conversations, medications, medical records—to protect themselves legally.
A strong community and access to legal resources can be life-saving during a wrongful accusation, even when facing the most serious criminal charges.
Systemic gaps in hospice and end-of-life care protocols can lead to tragic outcomes for caregivers who are simply doing their best.
…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus
The Story Begins on Reddit
Whit Misseldine introduces the episode, explaining that Rachel Waters' story originated from a Reddit post. The episode sets the stage for a deeply personal and traumatic narrative about caregiving, family estrangement, and wrongful accusation.
Childhood, Identity, and Early Trauma
Rachel shares her complex childhood—marked by intellectual precocity, social challenges, and a deep bond with her mother. She describes growing up in rural Georgia, her family’s military history, and her early diagnosis of autism spectrum traits, which were misunderstood at the time.
The Slow Unraveling of Her Mother’s Health
Rachel recounts her mother’s diagnosis with Alzheimer’s (APOE4 gene) and multiple myeloma, and the emotional and logistical toll of being her primary caregiver. She describes the family’s denial, lack of support, and growing suspicion toward her, despite her efforts to protect her mother.
The Final Days and the Comfort Care Kit
Rachel details the final days of her mother’s life in memory care, the conflict over pain management, and the critical moment when she used the comfort care kit to ease her mother’s suffering. She emphasizes her adherence to medical protocols and her belief in the sanctity of end-of-life dignity.
The Indictment and the Criminal Legal System
“I had seen enough indictments in my time as an investigator to know what they looked like. And it looked legit. I could not process it as real though because nothing like this existed anywhere in legal precedent.”
“I can live with scrutiny around who I am, my life, my lifestyle, my looks, my mistakes. I can live with all of that scrutiny. I cannot live with this happening to another person.”
“I don’t care if it’s 10, 15, 20 years down the line, me hearing about and thinking, oh, if I had ever gotten that law passed, that probably wouldn’t have happened. I couldn’t live with that.”
“I had seen enough indictments in my time as an investigator to know what they looked like. And it looked legit. I could not process it as real though because nothing like this existed anywhere in legal precedent.”
Host
Guest
Rachel Waters
person
Brian Steele
person
Hospice
organization
morphine
product
Georgia Bureau of Investigation
organization
Audible
organization
comfort care kit
other
Marsha's Law
other
multiple myeloma
other
other
401: What if you were ambushed on a dark desert highway?
This Is Actually Happening • 59m • 4/7/2026
402: What if a deadly tornado helped to heal old wounds?
This Is Actually Happening • 54m • 4/14/2026
403: What if your childhood bully actually apologized?
This Is Actually Happening • 48m • 4/21/2026
404: What if you were stricken with the flesh-eating disease?
This Is Actually Happening • 55m • 4/28/2026
Get the full intelligence
Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “405: What if you were accused of murdering your mother?” inside PodZeus.
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime