1967 09-17 Indians at Yankees
Get the full intelligence
Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “1967 09-17 Indians at Yankees” inside PodZeus.
This episode of the Thomas Paine Podcast presents a detailed radio broadcast of a pivotal 1967 baseball game between the Cleveland Indians and the New York Yankees at Yankee Stadium. The game, played on September 17, 1967, is a tense, back-and-forth contest that ends in a 4-2 victory for the Indians. The Yankees, who were in a tight American League pennant race, face off against a resilient Cleveland team that capitalizes on key mistakes and timely hitting. The game features multiple lead changes, dramatic defensive plays, and a dramatic ninth-inning finish when reliever Orlando Pena strikes out Charlie Smith to seal the win. The broadcast is rich with period-specific commentary, sponsor plugs for White Owl Cigars, Atlantic Imperial gasoline, and Kruger Pilsner beer, reflecting the commercial culture of mid-20th-century sports radio. The narrative captures the excitement and stakes of a season-defining game, with the Indians securing a crucial win that impacts the playoff race.
The Cleveland Indians defeated the New York Yankees 4-2 in a pivotal 1967 game that impacted the American League pennant race.
Pitching was dominant, with Louis Piant (11-9) earning the win and Mel Stottlemyre (14-13) taking the loss despite strong performances.
The game featured multiple lead changes, key defensive plays, and a dramatic ninth-inning finish with a strikeout by reliever Orlando Pena.
Sponsorships for White Owl Cigars, Atlantic Imperial gasoline, and Kruger Pilsner beer were woven throughout the broadcast, reflecting 1960s sports radio advertising.
The Yankees' inability to capitalize on base runners and defensive errors proved costly, especially in the final innings.
…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus
Opening Broadcast & Sponsorship Intro
The episode opens with a commercial break featuring sponsor ads for Shopify, Atlantic's Match the Red Ball game, White Owl Cigars, and Chipperillo cigars. The announcer, Bob Delaney, welcomes listeners to the game with pre-game lineup announcements and a playful teaser about future Hall of Famers.
Game Start & First Inning Action
The game begins with both teams' starting lineups introduced. Mel Stottlemyre takes the mound for the Yankees against Louis Piant of the Indians. The first inning sees both teams retire in order, with no runs scored. The broadcast highlights the tight pennant race and the importance of this final homestand game.
Second and Third Innings – Yankees Threaten, Indians Respond
The Yankees threaten in the bottom of the fourth with runners on first and second, but a double play by the Indians limits the damage to one run. The Indians tie the game in the top of the fifth with a series of hits, including a key infield hit by Richie Scheinblum and a run-scoring double by Willie Smith. The game is now 2-2.
Fifth and Sixth Innings – Momentum Shifts
The Indians take the lead in the top of the sixth with a two-run rally, including a sacrifice and a single by Joe Askew. The Yankees respond in the bottom of the sixth with a clutch double by Jerry Kenny, scoring Horace Clark to tie the game at 2-2. The broadcast captures the tension as both teams trade blows.
Seventh Inning Drama & Bases Loaded
“The little difference that makes the difference in your car's performance can be a clean carburetor.”
“Orlando Pena comes in to get the one man that he had to get, Charlie Smith. And the final score here is the Cleveland Indians 4 and the New York Yankees 2.”
“You get a lot more from the White House than just smoke.”
“The little difference that makes the difference in your car's performance can be a clean carburetor.”
Hosts
New York Yankees
other
Cleveland Indians
other
Mel Stottlemyre
person
Yankee Stadium
place
Kruger Pilsner
brand
Jerry Kenny
person
Louis Piant
person
White Owl Cigars
brand
Horace Clark
person
Atlantic Imperial Gasoline
brand
Part 3 -- The Idiot Tax: How to Stop Paying for Other People’s Stupidity
Thomas Paine Podcast • 31m • 3/31/2026
Part 2 -- The Idiot Tax: How to Stop Paying for Other People’s Stupidity
Thomas Paine Podcast • 29m • 3/31/2026
Part 1 -- The Idiot Tax: How to Stop Paying for Other People’s Stupidity
Thomas Paine Podcast • 31m • 3/31/2026
1965 06-14 Mets at Reds
Thomas Paine Podcast • 2h 26m • 4/1/2026
1974 04-09 Phillies at Cubs TV Audio
Thomas Paine Podcast • 2h 27m • 4/1/2026
Get the full intelligence
Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “1967 09-17 Indians at Yankees” inside PodZeus.
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime