How the myth of ‘two-tier policing’ took hold

Today in Focus27mJune 5, 2026
AI-Generated Summary

The death of 18-year-old Henry Novak, stabbed by Vikram Digwa and left dying while police dismissed his pleas for help, has been weaponized by the far right to promote the myth of 'two-tier policing'—the false claim that white people are systematically discriminated against by UK law enforcement. Despite the Novak family’s explicit plea to avoid division and their call for action on knife crime, figures like Nigel Farage and Tommy Robinson have seized on the tragedy to fuel racialized rhetoric, falsely asserting that minorities receive preferential treatment. This narrative, rooted in decades of far-right discourse and amplified by mainstream media and global influencers like Elon Musk, exploits genuine public anger over systemic failures while distorting the reality of institutional racism in policing. As anti-racist campaigners warn, the far right is now co-opting the language of civil rights movements—chanting 'no justice, no peace' and 'I can't breathe'—to position themselves as victims of oppression. Yet data shows Black Britons are seven times more likely to die after police restraint and overrepresented in use of force, proving the opposite. The real danger lies not in fairness to minorities, but in the erosion of trust in institutions and the normalization of conspiracy theories that serve political agendas more than justice.

Key Takeaways
1

The far right has weaponized Henry Novak’s death to promote the false 'two-tier policing' myth, despite the family’s call to avoid division.

2

Black Britons are seven times more likely than white people to die after police restraint, contradicting claims of preferential treatment for minorities.

3

Far-right groups are now co-opting civil rights slogans like 'I can't breathe' and 'no justice, no peace' to frame themselves as oppressed freedom fighters.

4

The myth thrives not on data, but on emotional manipulation, exploiting public anger over inequality and cultural change.

5

Elon Musk and international far-right figures are amplifying the narrative, using Britain as a 'canary in the coal mine' for their global anti-immigration agenda.

…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus

Chapters
0:00
2 min

The Rise of the Two-Tier Policing Myth

It feels a little bit like the genie's out of the bottle, partly because many of the individuals that passionately believe this haven't necessarily rationalised themselves into it. It's very hard to rationalise them out of it with evidence or statistics or facts. It's just a feeling, it's a sense.

Highlight
2:29
2 min

The Tragedy of Henry Novak

You have to absolutely start there. Immediately after the sentencing on Monday, Henry's father, Mark, said the family will carry the grief of this for every single day...

Highlight
4:34
2 min

The Co-Opting of Grief by the Far Right

And he's called for Digwa's family to be deported. And so here you almost see that there's a almost an arms race in terms of those two parties on the right of the spectrum, each of them trying to gain currency and to gain advantage from what?

Highlight
6:43
3 min

The Reality of Police Failures

Muir and Mulhall analyze the police response, emphasizing that the failure was not racial bias but gross incompetence. Officers ignored a young man in distress, despite clear statements of being stabbed and saying 'I can't breathe.'

9:24
2 min

The Origins and Evolution of the Myth

Jo Mulhall traces the 'two-tier policing' narrative back to the English Defence League and explains how it has evolved into a cornerstone of far-right ideology, now embraced by mainstream media and politicians.

High-Impact Quotes
Black people in Britain are seven times more likely than white people to die after police restraint. Black children in England and Wales, almost eight times more likely to be strip searched.
Jo Mulhall23:08
The figures do not support that. They know that. And so they almost have to resort to something that is all tune but no words.
Hugh Muir24:33
And he's called for Digwa's family to be deported. And so here you almost see that there's a almost an arms race in terms of those two parties on the right of the spectrum, each of them trying to gain currency and to gain advantage from what?
Hugh Muir6:05
Speakers

Host

Annie Kelly

Guests

Hugh MuirJo Mulhall
Topics Discussed
two-tier policing95%far-right politics90%institutional racism88%police accountability85%racialized rhetoric82%civil rights language78%media manipulation75%public trust in institutions70%
People & Brands

Henry Novak

person

12xNeutral

The Guardian

organization

10xNeutral

Vikram Digwa

person

8xNeutral

Nigel Farage

person

7xNegative

Met Police

organization

6xNegative

Tommy Robinson

person

6xNegative

Stephen Lawrence

person

5xNeutral

Black Lives Matter

other

5xNeutral

Elon Musk

person

4xNegative

Hope Not Hate

organization

4xPositive

Start discovering podcast insights today

Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.

No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime