WHO The If - GABY!
What if you knew exactly who you were working with for eight years? That’s the premise of a special What the If? episode celebrating the podcast’s eighth anniversary, where host Philip Shane and historian Matthew Stanley dive deep into the mind of microbiologist Gabby Panicia. What unfolds is a rare, intimate look at the hidden world of lab life—where Bunsen burners create invisible sterile fields, gloves protect both scientist and experiment, and even the most mundane lab bench is a battleground against ambient bacillus spores. Gabby reveals how her work on behavior-manipulating fungi forces her to think like a biologist, a naturalist, and a storyteller, all at once. She shares how her childhood fascination with Animal Planet and bug-catching evolved into a career that blends narrative curiosity with rigorous science. The episode also exposes the quiet crises of scientific life: the trap of being the only person who knows a technique, the emotional toll of being endlessly asked to ‘save the world’ with your research, and the invisible labor of building tools that no one else will use. Yet amid the chaos, there’s joy—finding herds of hermit crabs swapping shells on a Puerto Rican beach, or writing science fiction that’s really about people, not just science. This isn’t just a behind-the-scenes peek—it’s a manifesto for the quiet, invisible work that powers discovery. The episode’s most striking revelation?
Gloves protect both the scientist and the experiment—contamination can come from your skin, not just the lab.
A Bunsen burner creates a 'sterile field' through heat and airflow, a low-tech workaround for labs without tissue culture hoods.
Scientists often avoid asking 'stupid' questions because no one will tell you they’re outside the scope—so you learn to self-censor.
The most valuable lab skill is often invisible: being the only person who knows how to run a specific laser, which can trap you in grad school forever.
Biologists don’t all think alike—evolutionary biologists demand fitness proof, while neuroscientists demand behavioral specificity, even when the science is the same.
…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus
The Anniversary Special: Who Are We?
The episode opens with a celebration of What the If?'s eighth anniversary, setting the stage for a special 'Who the If?' format where the hosts explore each other's inner worlds.
The Birth of a Thought Experiment
Gabby shares how a reunion with her physics-grad friend sparked the idea for this episode: asking each other the burning questions they’ve had about each other’s work.
The Soundtrack of Science: Drilling and Construction
The team sets the mood with the constant construction noise downstairs, which becomes a metaphor for the relentless, often disruptive, rhythm of scientific work.
Inside Gabby’s Lab: The Invisible Rules of the Bench
Gabby describes her lab space—old-school black benches, wooden shelves, and the strict separation between 'science' and 'non-science' zones, where her computer lives.
The Two-Way Protection of Gloves
Gloves aren’t just for protection—they prevent the scientist from contaminating the experiment. Gabby shares a story about how even touching your face with gloves can ruin a culture.
“They're, the radio isotope tests they were doing were so ridiculously sensitive that they ended up getting a false positive because they had borrowed a bottle of acid from another lab and that lab 20 years before had had some plutonium in it.”
“Because the idea is that certain pathogens cause these behaviors in their host as a way to increase their fitness.”
“I'm like, oh, I think we can do this. And I'll do a couple of real quick experiments to get like proof of concept. But then I'm like, I have my own science to get back to.”
Host
Guest
What the If?
media
Gabby Panicia
person
Philip Shane
person
Matthew Stanley
person
Bunsen burner
product
microplastics
other
Harvard University
organization
New York University
organization
bacillus
other
Patreon
other
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime