The Last Take
Thirty years after her murder, Hollywood starlet Krista Helm’s daughter Nicole is determined to uncover the truth behind her mother’s brutal stabbing in 1977—a crime that has haunted her since she was nine. Krista, a dazzling yet volatile beauty who danced through the glittering worlds of Mick Jagger, Warren Beatty, and the Shah of Iran, lived a life of excess, ambition, and secrecy. Her diary, sex tapes, and a rumored $300,000 stash of drugs suggest she was playing with fire. Now, a new generation of detectives is reopening the cold case, unearthing a web of jealousy, betrayal, and possible mob ties. Tony Sirico, the future 'Pauly Walnuts' of *The Sopranos*, was seen cleaning out her apartment days after her death—taking her furs, tapes, and personal effects. Her closest friend, Lenny Barron, may have orchestrated the cover-up to protect her reputation. The investigation takes a shocking turn when DNA under Krista’s fingernails is traced to a woman—possibly her jealous lover, Patty Collins—though Patty denies ever being in California. Meanwhile, a decades-old theory resurfaces: the killer might be Lionel Williams, the man convicted of murdering Sal Mineo on the same day and in the same neighborhood. Though Williams was supposedly in jail at the time, new evidence suggests he wasn’t arrested until after Krista’s death—and was never questioned. As the case reopens, Nicole clings to the hope that justice, long delayed, may finally come.
Krista Helm’s murder on February 12, 1977, may have been tied to her secret sex tapes and diary, which could have exposed powerful people.
Tony Sirico was seen removing personal items from Krista’s apartment days after her death—possibly acting on orders from her friend Lenny Barron to protect her reputation.
DNA under Krista’s fingernails came from a woman, suggesting a female assailant—possibly her jealous lover Patty Collins—though Patty denies ever being in California.
The original suspect in Sal Mineo’s murder, Lionel Williams, was not arrested until after Krista’s death and was never questioned about her case—raising serious doubts about the original investigation.
Krista had a pattern of provoking jealousy: she cut off her sister, betrayed lovers, and flaunted affairs with both men and women, making her many enemies.
…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus
The Dream That Never Was
Nicole Helm, Krista’s daughter, recounts her mother’s murder at age nine and her lifelong quest to uncover the truth behind her mother’s death, driven by a dream of reunion that was never fulfilled.
The Starlet Who Played with the Big Boys
Krista Helm’s rise from Milwaukee to Hollywood, her glamorous lifestyle, and her connections with icons like Mick Jagger, Warren Beatty, and the Shah of Iran, paint a picture of a woman who lived dangerously.
The Diary, the Tapes, and the Threats
Krista kept a secret sex diary and recorded intimate moments with celebrities, possibly planning a tell-all book. Her friends feared she was in over her head—and her disappearance of these materials raises red flags.
The Night She Was Killed
On February 12, 1977, Krista was stabbed 22 times in West Hollywood. A neighbor heard a scream but saw nothing. The crime scene was chaotic, with no witnesses and no clear motive.
The Cold Case Reopened
After decades, detectives Larry Brandenburg and Tom Harris take up the case, re-examining evidence, interviewing old witnesses, and uncovering new leads, including the role of Tony Sirico and Lenny Barron.
“Sal Mineo's killer is the same killer that killed Krista Helm. In my own mind, I'm so sure of that, I bet the deed to my house that he is A1 number one suspect.”
“I believe that the person is still out there and I believe that we're going to find closure one day for my mom and we're going to find justice.”
“We believe we have an idea where he is living, and we believe that he's not that far away, and we're going to go talk to him.”
Host
Guests
Krista Helm
person
Nicole Helm
person
Larry Brandenburg
person
Debbie Danilo
person
Tom Harris
person
Tony Sirico
person
Larry Gansey
person
Lionel Williams
person
Patty Collins
person
Lenny Barron
person
Case 340: Elisabeth Membrey
1h 34m • 5/30/2026
Closing Time (PODCAST EXCLUSIVE EPISODE)
37m • 6/1/2026
Presenting the Lindbergh Conspiracies
42m • 6/1/2026
True Crime Vault: The Confession?
1h 24m • 6/2/2026
The Devil Wore White - Update
1h 22m • 6/2/2026
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime

