Closing Time (PODCAST EXCLUSIVE EPISODE)
In 1992, 24-year-old Lisa Ziegert vanished after her evening shift at Brittany's Card and Gift Shop in Agawam, Massachusetts, leaving behind her car, belongings, and a cryptic note. Despite a massive investigation involving 400 suspects, no security footage, and no eyewitnesses, the case went cold for over two decades. The breakthrough came in 2017 when advances in DNA phenotyping allowed investigators to create a physical profile of the killer—revealing a Caucasian man with dark hair and brown or hazel eyes. This led to a warrant for DNA from 11 previously uncooperative suspects. One of them, Gary Shera, a man who had visited the store weeks before to buy a gift for his wife, confessed in writing after realizing he was about to be caught. He had become obsessed with Lisa during a routine visit, and on the night of her murder, acted on a long-suppressed fantasy of abduction and violence. Shera was arrested, pleaded guilty, and sentenced to life in prison. The case, once dismissed as a random attack, revealed how a single, hidden obsession can erupt into tragedy with no warning. The story underscores how cold cases can remain unsolved not due to lack of effort, but because of technological limitations. In the 1990s, investigators had no way to run DNA against a database—each sample had to be matched manually to a suspect. Even when suspects were ruled out, the truth remained buried.
DNA phenotyping allowed investigators to create a physical profile of a killer 25 years after the crime, leading to a breakthrough in a cold case.
The killer, Gary Shera, was a stranger who became obsessed with Lisa after a routine visit to the store, proving that some murders stem from hidden, unchecked fantasies.
In the 1990s, police had no way to run DNA against a database—each sample had to be matched manually, making large-scale investigations nearly impossible.
A wife’s tip about her husband’s involvement was dismissed in 1993 due to her alcoholism and ongoing divorce, but it was later validated as crucial evidence.
The killer confessed in writing after realizing he was about to be caught, showing how psychological pressure can break even the most composed criminals.
…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus
The Empty House and the Three Envelopes
“One of them was her boyfriend's last will and testament. Another was a note that was for her. And the third was a letter that was addressed to the family of a woman who had been murdered 25 years earlier.”
Lisa's Final Evening Shift
On April 15, 1992, Lisa Ziegert, a teacher's aide and gift shop employee, works her late shift. She’s anxious, feels watched, and is visited by her sister Lynn. After a routine transaction at 8:20 p.m., she goes into the back room—never to be seen again.
The Discovery and the First Clues
The next morning, a coworker finds the shop unlocked, lights on, and Lisa’s belongings present. Detective Wayne Macy arrives and discovers blood-stained cardboard boxes in the back room and scuff marks in the alley. No security footage exists, and the only clue is a cash register receipt from 8:20 p.m.
The Body in the Woods
“She was partially naked and some of her clothes that she still had on had been pulled down, so it seemed fairly obvious that she had been sexually assaulted before she died.”
The Year-Long Investigation and Dead Ends
Macy spends a full year chasing 400 leads—ranging from a man who stares at women at a gym to a fake police car sighting. Despite exhaustive efforts, no DNA match is found, and suspects like Blair and Ed are ruled out. The case grows colder.
“She was partially naked and some of her clothes that she still had on had been pulled down, so it seemed fairly obvious that she had been sexually assaulted before she died.”
“Because this was the early 90s, there was no way to have one DNA sample like you would find on a body, let's say, and then just put it into a bank and see what turns up. That didn't exist.”
“The killer had always been fascinated by abduction and bondage ever since they were young. And they had done their best to try to, you know, keep those fantasies inside and not act on them.”
Host
Detective Wayne Macy
person
Lisa Ziegert
person
Gary Shera
person
Brittany's Card and Gift Shop
other
Agawam Police Department
organization
Ed Borgatti
person
Blair Masoya
person
Anthony Galluni
person
Unsolved Mysteries
media
James Dent
person
Case 340: Elisabeth Membrey
1h 34m • 5/30/2026
The After Show: New Updates on the Gilgo Beach Murders
27m • 6/8/2026
Milagros Nieves (3 of Clubs, Connecticut)
35m • 6/10/2026
Long Island Serial Killer Part 3
1h 4m • 6/1/2026
Mom Discovers Her 13 Year Old Son Just Killed Someone
1h 3m • 6/1/2026
Deadly Plans
30m • 6/11/2026
Teke Teke | Campfire Stories with MrBallen
26m • 6/12/2026
Killer Profile (PODCAST EXCLUSIVE EPISODE)
39m • 6/15/2026
Lived Once, Buried Twice (PODCAST EXCLUSIVE EPISODE)
26m • 6/17/2026
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime