Ep 532: The Truth About Annuities: Busting Myths and Answering Your Biggest Questions

HerMoney with Jean Chatzky34mJune 17, 2026
AI-Generated Summary

Annuities are not the financial snake oil many believe them to be—but they’re also not a one-size-fits-all solution. In this episode, Jean Chatzky debunks the myth that annuities are designed solely to enrich sellers, revealing instead that their fees are baked into the product like mortgage commissions, and that the real value lies in risk pooling: by sharing longevity risk across a large group, annuities allow retirees to spend 30–35% more annually than they could if they tried to fund their own retirement. The conversation with LIMRA’s Michael Finca and Tamako Toland explains how income annuities function like modern pensions, and how savings annuities with living benefits offer flexibility for those planning ahead. A key revelation? Women receive lower payouts than men—not due to discrimination, but because they live longer on average, making the pricing actuarially fair. The episode ends with a clear, actionable roadmap: define your income needs, assess your lifestyle gap, and consult a financial professional who aligns with your goals—because retirement planning isn’t just about money, it’s about peace of mind. The most powerful takeaway? Annuities aren’t about maximizing returns—they’re about minimizing the fear of outliving your money. For many, especially those without pensions or with high risk tolerance, a fixed annuity can act as a behavioral anchor, allowing the rest of their portfolio to take more risk.

Key Takeaways
1

Annuities allow retirees to spend 30–35% more annually by pooling longevity risk across a large group, reducing the need to save for extreme longevity.

2

The cost of an annuity is not a fee—it’s an insurance premium, similar to car or home insurance, where you pay a small amount upfront for a guaranteed income stream.

3

Women receive lower annuity payouts than men not due to discrimination, but because they live longer on average, making the pricing actuarially fair.

4

Buying a fixed annuity 5–10 years before retirement is ideal—it allows time for the premium to grow and provides a clear income forecast, like a pension.

5

A living benefit annuity offers flexibility: you can guarantee lifetime income while retaining access to the underlying account value.

…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus

Chapters
0:00
2 min

The Myth of the Annuity

The episode opens with a brief intro to the podcast's mission before shifting to the central theme: annuities are misunderstood. Jean Chatzky sets the stage by acknowledging the confusion and fear surrounding annuities, framing the episode as a myth-busting session with experts.

2:12
3 min

What Is an Annuity? The Economic Definition

An annuity is an umbrella. And the best way to think of an annuity is a set of laws and a tax structure that defines a certain class of investment-like products.

Highlight
4:46
5 min

Annuities as Retirement Savings Tools

Tamako Toland clarifies that annuities aren’t just income products—they’re also retirement savings vehicles. She explains fixed and fixed indexed annuities, emphasizing their role in providing guaranteed income with a minimum floor, and compares them to 401ks and IRAs.

9:21
8 min

The Real Cost of Annuities: Fees vs. Insurance

You can spend about 30 to 35 percent more every year by pooling that risk of not knowing how long you're going to live with other retirees.

Highlight
16:58
7 min

The Annuity Puzzle: Why Doesn’t Everyone Buy One?

The insurance company wins. But really, it's these people who are living a long time who are winning, quote unquote.

Highlight
High-Impact Quotes
You can spend about 30 to 35 percent more every year by pooling that risk of not knowing how long you're going to live with other retirees.
Michael Finca17:23
An annuity is an umbrella. And the best way to think of an annuity is a set of laws and a tax structure that defines a certain class of investment -like products.
Michael Finca3:06
The insurance company wins. But really, it's these people who are living a long time who are winning, quote unquote.
Michael Finca16:58
Speakers

Host

Jean Chatzky

Guests

Michael FincaTamako Toland
Topics Discussed
annuity myths95%retirement income planning90%longevity risk pooling90%gender and annuity payouts88%fixed annuities85%living benefit annuities80%retirement savings tools75%financial planning for women70%
People & Brands

Michael Finca

person

15xPositive

Tamako Toland

person

14xPositive

Jean Chatzky

person

12xNeutral

LIMRA's Retirement Income Institute

organization

5xNeutral

Whisker Litter Robot

brand

3xPositive

Omaha Steaks

brand

3xPositive

Weight Loss by HERS

brand

2xPositive

Monarch

brand

2xPositive

ForHers

brand

2xPositive

LIMRA

organization

2xNeutral

Start discovering podcast insights today

Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.

No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime