What if the Phillies Traded for Tarik Skubal?
What if the Phillies traded for Tarik Skubal? That's the provocative question at the heart of this week's Hittin' Season episode, as hosts Justin Clue and Liz Roescher dissect a season defined by razor-thin margins and offensive stagnation. Despite a 7-2 record in their last nine games and a sweep of the San Diego Padres, the Phillies remain a team built on pitching survival rather than offensive firepower. Their 3.2 runs per game average and .204 batting average from right-handed hitters paint a grim picture, with Adolis García's recent surge offering only fleeting hope. The real tension lies in the trade deadline rumors: while the Detroit Tigers' ace Tarik Skubal is sidelined with elbow surgery, his potential availability has ignited speculation. Jeff Passan explicitly named the Phillies as the best fit for Skubal, citing their need to shore up a rotation that already features Aaron Nola, Cristopher Sanchez, and Zack Wheeler. Yet the episode reveals a deeper truth: the Phillies' identity is now defined by a desperate gamble—investing in elite pitching while hoping their offense can somehow catch up. With no viable backup plan for struggling hitters and a roster devoid of depth, the team’s future hinges on whether they can pull off a blockbuster trade or simply survive on the edge of collapse. The conversation pivots from fantasy to reality as the podcast turns to the Phillies' upcoming series against the unexpectedly strong Chicago White Sox.
The Phillies are winning with a 3.2 runs per game average, the lowest in the league, making their success unsustainable long-term.
Adolis García's recent offensive surge is promising but remains a small sample size; he's the only right-handed hitter with any power potential.
The Phillies' offensive depth is nonexistent—right-handed hitters are hitting .204 with a .581 OPS, and there's no backup plan if García fails.
Tarik Skubal is the top trade target for the Phillies, but his elbow surgery and the Tigers' lack of urgency make a deal unlikely.
The Phillies' rotation could become the best in baseball with Skubal, but their offense would still be the weakest in the league.
…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus
The Phillies Sweep the Padres, But at What Cost?
The hosts reflect on the Phillies' season sweep of the Padres, noting the team's 7-2 record in their last nine games. Despite the wins, the offense remains alarmingly weak, scoring just 3.2 runs per game and failing to reach 30 runs in nine games.
The Offensive Crisis: A Team Built on Pitching Survival
The episode dives into the Phillies' offensive struggles, with right-handed hitters hitting just .204 and a .581 OPS. The team has no backup plan if Adolis García fails, and the lack of depth is a recurring theme.
The Field of Dreams Game: A Fan's Dream, A Fan's Nightmare
The hosts react to the ticket lottery for the Field of Dreams game, which is restricted to Iowa residents. They mock the absurdity of excluding Phillies fans and imagine a sea of Phillies fans lurking in the cornfields.
The Skubal Trade Rumor: A Fantasy for the Phillies?
“Considering how good Kyle Schwarber, Bryce Harper and Brandon Marsh have been, it's embarrassing that the Phillies have scored fewer runs than Kansas City and Boston. That is embarrassing.”
The White Sox: A Young, Fun, and Dangerous Team
The hosts preview the upcoming series against the Chicago White Sox, who are 33-29 and second in the AL Central. Despite losing their star slugger Murakami, the team is still dangerous with breakout performances from Vargas and Peters.
“Considering how good Kyle Schwarber, Bryce Harper and Brandon Marsh have been, it's embarrassing that the Phillies have scored fewer runs than Kansas City and Boston. That is embarrassing.”
“We are free people and we should be free to eat any and all of these. They're really making it difficult because they've turned this into like a banana pudding. Like a... A bit of pudding, but in a split and I'm having a hard time with because I like the rib melt as well.”
“It's a terrifying way to play baseball. It's a terrifying way to watch baseball. You are hanging on by your fingernails every single, you know, the top of every inning when you're at home.”
Host
Guest
Liz Roescher
person
Justin Clue
person
Chicago White Sox
other
San Diego Padres
other
Adolis Garcia
person
Tarik Skubal
person
Aaron Nola
person
Christopher Sanchez
person
Zack Wheeler
person
Jeff Passan
person
TAA 12 - Hitters Who Caught Our Eye
1h 4m • 5/30/2026
Phillies Face Another First-Place Foe
53m • 6/12/2026
Is This the Worst Phillies Offense Ever?
52m • 6/2/2026
A Perfectly Imperfect Union: Reflecting on America 250 with Raquel Borras
28m • 5/30/2026
SHOCKING Reports Have The Blue Jays As *FAVOURITES* To Land This SUPERSTAR…. | Blue Jays Rumours & Breakdown
40m • 6/2/2026
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime