COLTS SQUAD SHOW: 10 Most IMPACTFUL Colts of the Last 10 Years for Locked On's 10th Anniversary!

The Indianapolis Colts' last decade has been defined not by on-field triumphs, but by a relentless carousel of quarterback turmoil, organizational chaos, and missed opportunities. As the Locked On Podcast Network celebrates its 10th anniversary, the Colts Squad Show confronts the painful reality: despite having some of the most impactful individual players in franchise history—including Andrew Luck, Jonathan Taylor, and Quentin Nelson—the team has only made two playoff appearances and one win since 2016. The conversation reveals a franchise in a state of limbo, where the ripple effects of Luck’s abrupt retirement still haunt the organization, and the constant quarterback churn has turned the Colts into a laughingstock of NFL dysfunction. The hosts don’t sugarcoat it: this era is being remembered not for memorable wins, but for the biggest lead blown in NFL history, a parade of interim coaches, and a quarterback market so dysfunctional it’s now considering a college player with a $90,000 gambling history. The episode ends with a firm consensus: the Colts are not just a football team in decline—they’re a cautionary tale of how a once-stable franchise can unravel when leadership fails to protect its foundation. The show’s most striking revelation isn’t just the list of top players, but the collective admission that the most impactful player of the last decade might be Andrew Luck—by virtue of the devastation his departure caused.