NEED HELP: White Sox’s CATCHING crisis ESCALATES, but it is doubtful they TRADE for Adley Rutschman
The Chicago White Sox are facing a critical catching crisis with Kyle Teal out injured, and while Adley Rutschman appears to be the ideal upgrade, host Todd Walter argues it's nearly impossible the team will trade for him. Despite Rutschman's elite offensive and defensive numbers, the White Sox are unlikely to part with their prized pitching prospect Hagan Smith, especially since GM Chris Getz must plan for a long-term future under owner Jerry Reinsdorf, who doesn’t pay for pitching. Walter highlights that the Orioles are not entertaining a trade now, even with their playoff hopes alive, and that trading a first-round pick for a one-and-a-half-year rental doesn’t align with the front office’s risk-averse, process-driven philosophy. Instead, he predicts the White Sox will target cheaper, short-term upgrades like Gary Sanchez or Carson Kelly. The episode also dives into roster decisions, with Jordan Hicks unlikely to be DFA’d despite his poor performance, and Eric Fetty expected to stay unless he collapses. Walter makes a bold case that strikeouts aren’t the worst out—run-losing plays like grounders to third with runners on base are far worse—arguing that high-strikeout sluggers like Colson should be embraced for their run production.
The White Sox will not trade for Adley Rutschman this season due to the cost of Hagan Smith and the Orioles' unwillingness to sell now.
Rutschman's 267/343/49 slash line and 132 WRC+ make him a massive upgrade over Drew Romo and Edgar Carroll.
The White Sox are unlikely to trade their first-round pick Hagan Smith for a player they’ll only keep for 1.5 years.
Chris Getz is focused on long-term pitching depth and won’t sacrifice young, cheap talent for short-term gains.
The team will likely target backup catchers like Gary Sanchez or Carson Kelly instead of making a blockbuster trade.
…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus
The Catching Crisis and the Rutschman Trade Myth
“I would be stunned if the White Sox pulled off such a bold move.”
Why Rutschman Is Off the Table
Walter breaks down three reasons the Rutschman trade is unlikely: the Orioles aren’t entertaining it now, the cost of Hagan Smith is too high, and the front office must plan for long-term pitching depth under Reinsdorf.
The Real Targets: Sanchez, Kelly, and the Process-Driven Front Office
Instead of Rutschman, the White Sox are more likely to pursue lower-cost, short-term upgrades like Gary Sanchez or Carson Kelly, aligning with their conservative, process-focused approach.
The Sunk Cost Dilemma: Hicks, Benetendi, and the Front Office Philosophy
Walter analyzes the team’s reluctance to cut losing contracts like Jordan Hicks and Andrew Benetendi, explaining that the front office avoids sunk cost and values long-term roster flexibility.
Roster Moves: Schultz, Montgomery, and the Future of the Bullpen
With Noah Schultz returning from the IL, Walter predicts Braden Montgomery will be promoted, and Eric Fetty will likely move to the bullpen unless he struggles.
“The second worst out is anything that leads to a double play because it's two outs. Then the strikeout, because yes, the ball was never put in play.”
“And I would be stunned if the White Sox pulled off such a bold move.”
“And that's what I think on the traditionalist side we have to embrace. It's about runs. That's what the modern day thinking is. It should always be about runs, not average.”
Host
Adley Rutschman
person
Hagan Smith
person
Todd Walter
person
Jordan Hicks
person
Chris Getz
person
Eric Fetty
person
Kyle Teal
person
David Sandlin
person
Noah Schultz
person
Jerry Reinsdorf
person
NO PANIC: White Sox FACE a daunting June schedule with CONFIDENCE despite losing Munetaka Murakami
30m • 6/1/2026
REWARD: Miguel Vargas’ remarkable Chicago White Sox RISE DESERVES an All-Star selection
31m • 6/2/2026
Daily Fantasy Baseball News and Notes I First Pitch Podcast 6/6/26
15m • 6/6/2026
CONTENDER OR PRETENDER: White Sox offense CARRIES team while pitching REMAINS major October concern
30m • 6/8/2026
BASK IN THE GLOW: White Sox rise to first place as Davis Martin and young lineup TOPPLES Chris Sale
30m • 6/11/2026
CRAZY GOOD: Sam Antonacci’s relentless drive should ENERGIZE the Chicago White Sox lineup for years
29m • 6/4/2026
BOLD MOVE: White Sox could SHAKE UP season with a suggested trade for Reid Detmers
30m • 6/5/2026
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime

