BOLD MOVE: White Sox could SHAKE UP season with a suggested trade for Reid Detmers

Locked On White Sox - Daily Podcast On The Chicago White Sox30mJune 5, 2026
AI-Generated Summary

The Chicago White Sox might be on the verge of a pivotal decision: whether to pursue veteran starting pitcher Reid Detmers at the trade deadline, despite the risks of trading away top prospects. Host Todd Welter argues that Detmers—currently a dominant reliever with a 3.125 ERA and 2025 club control—could be a low-cost, high-reward addition for a team desperate for starting depth. While Detmers' 2023–2024 seasons were marred by command issues, his bullpen transformation has made him one of the top 50 relievers in baseball, with a 95.8 mph fastball and elite strikeout rates. Welter warns that acquiring him would likely require giving up a top 10 prospect, but he sees Detmers as a safer bet than trading for division rivals like Seth Lugo or Michael Wacha, who could return to bite the White Sox 13 times a year. The episode also dives into the looming draft decision, where the White Sox face pressure to pick UCLA shortstop Brock Chowalski—but fear that a shadowy figure with influence over owner Jerry Reinsdorf could derail the process and steer the team toward a risky high school pick. Welter emphasizes that the draft choice is not a 'Rock or nothing' decision, with Georgia Tech catcher Vaughn Lackey and prep shortstop Grady Emerson emerging as strong alternatives. The fan poll shows cautious optimism about the team surviving a brutal June schedule without Munitaka Marikame, with 66% of respondents expressing 'somewhat confidence.

Key Takeaways
1

Reid Detmers, despite a rocky start, has become one of the top 50 relievers in MLB with a 3.125 ERA and 95.8 mph fastball, making him a low-cost, high-reward trade target.

2

Acquiring Detmers would likely require giving up a top 10 prospect, but his club control through 2028 and lower salary make him a smarter trade than acquiring division rivals like Lugo or Wacha.

3

The White Sox face a critical draft decision: Brock Chowalski remains the favorite, but Vaughn Lackey and Grady Emerson are strong alternatives with higher ceilings.

4

A shadow figure with influence over owner Jerry Reinsdorf could hijack the draft, potentially steering the team toward a risky high school pick instead of a proven college prospect.

5

Fan sentiment shows cautious optimism about surviving the brutal June schedule without Munitaka Marikame, with 66% of fans expressing 'somewhat confidence'.

…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus

Chapters
0:02
3 min

Intro & Club Membership Offer

The episode opens with a promotional pitch for the Everydayer Club, a subscription service offering ad-free access to the Locked On Podcast Network, exclusive Discord access, and a seven-day free trial.

3:00
3 min

Trade Deadline Speculation: Reid Detmers

Detmers makes sense. It's Detmers. I've listened to it a bunch of times, at least how I've heard the pronunciation makes sense for the White Sox, not only because of the cheaper deal and the club control, but also because he's what Sean Newcomb couldn't do.

Highlight
6:00
4 min

Detmers’ Career Arc: From Struggles to Reliever Success

Welter details Detmers’ 2023–2024 struggles with command and home runs, his move to the bullpen in 2025, and his transformation into a top-tier reliever with a 95.8 mph fastball and 3.125 ERA.

10:00
4 min

Trade Cost & Prospects: The Price of a Veteran Arm

Welter discusses the high cost of acquiring veteran arms like Detmers, Lugo, or Wacha—likely requiring a top 10 prospect—and argues against trading with division rivals to avoid future matchups.

14:00
4 min

Draft Decision: Chowalski vs. Alternatives

The episode shifts to the upcoming draft, where Welter weighs the pros and cons of selecting UCLA shortstop Brock Chowalski versus alternatives like Georgia Tech’s Vaughn Lackey and prep shortstop Grady Emerson.

High-Impact Quotes
And Depmers makes sense. It's Depmers. I've listened to it a bunch of times, at least how I've heard the pronunciation makes sense for the White Sox, not only because of the cheaper deal and the club control, but also because he's what Sean Newcomb couldn't do.
Todd Welter4:56
But my biggest fear is the organization takes neither because the shadow of Tony La Russa and Jerry Reinsdorf hover around this organization.
Todd Welter15:34
If he can step up right here and now and help this team when they need him the most, and he doesn't have to be Superman. But if he can maintain this decent hitting that he's been doing over the past six, seven games, I'm fine.
Todd Welter29:20
Speakers

Host

Todd Welter
Topics Discussed
reid detmers trade92%white sox trade deadline88%mlb draft prospects85%chicago white sox rebuilding80%minor league prospects75%mlb bullpen performance70%draft decision making68%white sox schedule65%
People & Brands

chicago white sox

other

45xNeutral

reid detmers

person

18xPositive

brent chowalski

person

12xPositive

graham emerson

person

8xPositive

locked on podcast network

organization

8xPositive

jerry reinsdorf

person

7xNeutral

vaughn lackey

person

6xPositive

jeff passan

person

6xNeutral

andrew benintendi

person

5xPositive

miguel vargas

person

5xPositive

Start discovering podcast insights today

Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.

No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime