Karine Premont and Christopher J. Devine eds., "Second in Command: Reevaluating the Role of Vice Presidents and Running Mates in Modern American Politics" (U Michigan Press, 2026)
The vice presidency, long dismissed as a ceremonial afterthought, has evolved into a pivotal yet informal power center in American governance—driven not by constitutional authority but by presidential choice. In their edited volume *Second in Command*, Christopher J. Devine and Karine Premont reveal how the role transformed after Walter Mondale’s 1976 campaign, when Jimmy Carter and Mondale formalized a new model: a vice president as a trusted, omnipresent advisor with access to all intelligence and decision-making circles. This shift, rooted in the post-1972 Democratic primary reforms that gave presidential nominees months to vet running mates, turned the VP into the 'last person in the room'—a role that amplifies influence without expanding formal power. The book dismantles the myth of the VP as powerless, citing historical instances where figures like Henry Wilson and John Nance Garner actively checked presidential overreach, even as recently as January 6th. Meanwhile, the authors expose a paradox in modern elections: while running mates are more popular within their own party than ever, they are simultaneously more polarizing and less effective at swaying independents or the opposing base. This growing partisanship, combined with the VP’s dual legislative-executive status, suggests a role that is both uniquely elected by the nation and deeply constrained by the president’s will.
The modern vice presidency is not defined by the Constitution but by presidential choice—access, inclusion in meetings, and intelligence briefings are granted, not mandated.
Since Walter Mondale’s 1976 campaign, vice presidents have been selected months in advance, enabling formalized role negotiations that created the 'last person in the room' model.
Historically, vice presidents like Henry Wilson and John Nance Garner have publicly opposed presidential overreach, proving that checks on power are not unprecedented.
Running mates are now more popular within their own party than ever, but also more polarizing—Kamala Harris and Mike Pence were the most popular among their parties, yet the least popular among the opposition.
The vice president is the only elected official besides the president who is chosen by the entire electorate, giving them a unique democratic mandate that can be leveraged for influence.
…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus
Introducing the Book and Its Origins
Lily Gorn introduces the book *Second in Command* and its co-editors, Christopher Devine and Karine Premont. Devine explains the book grew from a 2022 APSA conference where scholars of the vice presidency gathered, seeking to elevate a field often dismissed as secondary to presidential studies.
The Evolution of the Modern Vice Presidency
“This has been again a trend for about 50 years that they are they have an office in the West Wing close to the president, close to the Oval Office. They have complete access to the paper flow within the White House. They're getting all the intelligence briefings. They are generally understood to be welcome to any meeting they wish to attend and again potentially be that last person that talks to the president.”
The Constitutional Paradox: Power Without Authority
The chapter explores the irony that while the vice president’s formal powers are minimal—presiding over the Senate, opening electoral votes—their informal influence has grown dramatically. Devine emphasizes that this power is not legally guaranteed but rests on presidential discretion.
Historical Checks on Presidential Power
“There are instances in the past through American history, I'd say this is our most deeply historical chapter, by the way, covering more of the entire history. Most of these chapters focus on the last half century or so. Reb goes through some past examples where vice presidents in office have attempted at least to check the power of the president.”
Gender, Media, and the Modern Running Mate
“When you study the attitude toward these candidates... their popularity over time, it is going down. It's not one single candidate who did it. Our take, I think broadly be if I can try to speak for her as well here, is that it's part of our more polarized political environment...”
“We often hear we regularly see in print people saying that the president is the only person who is elected by the American people as a whole. It's actually not true. There's one other person. This is one of their distinct fact about VPs.”
“There are instances in the past through American history, I'd say this is our most deeply historical chapter, by the way, covering more of the entire history. Most of these chapters focus on the last half century or so. Reb goes through some past examples where vice presidents in office have attempted at least to check the power of the president.”
“This has been again a trend for about 50 years that they are they have an office in the West Wing close to the president, close to the Oval Office. They have complete access to the paper flow within the White House. They're getting all the intelligence briefings. They are generally understood to be welcome to any meeting they wish to attend and again potentially be that last person that talks to the president.”
Host
Guest
Christopher J. Devine
person
Karine Premont
person
Walter Mondale
person
Kamala Harris
person
Jimmy Carter
person
Mike Pence
person
Joe Biden
person
Dick Cheney
person
University of Michigan Press
organization
January 6th
other
Hour 3: Taking Yourself Too Seriously
38m • 6/9/2026
Democrats Search for a Lifeline in Growing Identity Crisis
12m • 5/30/2026
From Tehran to the Border Trump Bets Big on Strength Strategy
33m • 5/30/2026
Matthew McConaughey and Dave Portnoy - Megyn Kelly's "Double Feature" of Fascinating Interviews
2h 41m • 5/31/2026
Ep. 256 AMERICA IS PIVOTING
59m • 6/1/2026
Gary Hoover, "Ladder or Lottery: Economic Promises and the Reality of Who Gets Ahead" (U California Press, 2026)
1h 12m • 5/30/2026
The Predictable Shock of Brexit: Cultural Dissonance and the Rise of Populism with Iain Quinn
32m • 6/1/2026
Alex Law, "The Roots of Sociology: Scottish Enlightenment and the Civilising Process" (Routledge, 2026)
1h 34m • 6/2/2026
Courtney Rickert McCaffrey et al., "Geostrategy By Design: How to Manage Geopolitical Risk in The New Era of Globalization" (Disruption Books, 2024)
1h 9m • 6/5/2026
Margaret O’Mara on the Clintons, Tech, and Memory
1h 11m • 6/8/2026
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime

