Steven Nadler, "Spinoza, Atheist" (Princeton UP, 2026)

Princeton UP Ideas Podcast40mJune 2, 2026
AI-Generated Summary

Spinoza wasn't just a heretic—he was an atheist, argues philosopher Stephen Nadler in his new book, 'Spinoza, Atheist.' Contrary to the popular image of Spinoza as a pantheist who saw God in nature, Nadler insists that Spinoza’s radical rejection of divine intervention, worship, and supernatural agency makes him not a pantheist but a true atheist. For Spinoza, God is not a being to be revered, but nature itself—understood through reason, not awe. This distinction isn’t just semantic; it’s existential. Nadler shows how Spinoza’s Ethics, though written in the language of theology, systematically dismantles religious authority by replacing faith with intellectual clarity. The real danger of misreading Spinoza as a pantheist, Nadler warns, is that it smuggles in the very superstition he fought against—wonder, reverence, and mystical awe. Instead, Spinoza’s vision is one of liberation through knowledge: freedom comes not from divine grace, but from understanding the causal order of nature. Even more strikingly, Nadler reveals that Spinoza believed moral virtue could be cultivated through imagination and narrative—even if those beliefs were false—so long as they inspired justice and kindness. In a world where belief often masks behavior, Spinoza’s enduring legacy may be the radical idea that a good life doesn’t require God at all.

Key Takeaways
1

Spinoza’s God is nature, not a being worthy of worship—making him an atheist, not a pantheist.

2

Wonder is not a virtue for Spinoza—it’s born of ignorance and must be replaced with rational understanding.

3

Spinoza believed false religious beliefs could still lead to virtue if they inspire justice and kindness.

4

The Ethics was withheld from publication during Spinoza’s life because it was too radical, even for tolerant Holland.

5

Spinoza’s philosophy is a system of liberation through reason, not faith—freedom is knowing what’s truly in your best interest.

…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus

Chapters
0:00
2 min

Sponsor: We Buy Books

Promotion for We Buy Books, a service that pays users cash for unwanted books via app or online ISBN entry, with a 15% bonus code for first-time users.

1:53
1 min

Welcome to the New Books Network

Introduction to the New Books Network podcast in Jewish Studies, welcoming guest Stephen Nadler.

2:50
2 min

Spinoza: The Radical Philosopher

Introduction to Spinoza’s life, his excommunication from the Amsterdam Jewish community in 1656, and his foundational works: The Ethics and Theological-Political Treatise.

4:41
2 min

Spinoza’s Heretical God: Nature as God

Spinoza’s view that God is nature—no transcendent being, no providence, no miracles—making his philosophy fundamentally atheistic.

6:48
2 min

The Dutch Republic’s Religious Diversity

The cosmopolitan religious landscape of 17th-century Holland, where radical ideas could flourish—yet even this tolerance couldn’t accommodate Spinoza.

High-Impact Quotes
Part of Bale's point is that people's lives are not led according to their beliefs, they're led according to their feelings.
Stephen Nadler33:18
Yeah, wonder for Spinoza is bred in ignorance. We wonder about things where we either don't understand the causes that have brought them about or don't understand the effects that we might anticipate from them.
Stephen Nadler23:25
Spinoza is so hard to interpret that he functions as a kind of Rorschach. People see in him exactly what they want to see.
Stephen Nadler25:49
Speakers

Host

Ape Silberstein

Guest

Stephen Nadler
Topics Discussed
spinoza atheism95%theological political treatise90%spinoza ethics88%pantheism vs atheism87%biblical criticism85%virtue without god83%spinoza biography80%spinoza and wonder75%
People & Brands

baruch spinoza

person

32xNeutral

stephen nadler

person

15xPositive

dutch reformed church

organization

4xNegative

princeton university press

organization

4xPositive

new books network

organization

3xNeutral

we buy books

organization

3xNeutral

amsterdam portuguese jewish community

organization

3xNeutral

descartes

person

3xNeutral

galileo

person

2xNeutral

catholic church

organization

2xNegative

Start discovering podcast insights today

Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.

No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime