Set 2: Preparing for the Parade (w/ Jess Smetana)
The episode captures the euphoric aftermath of the New York Knicks' NBA championship win through the lens of Jess Smetana, a devoted Knicks fan and fiancée of a lifelong fan. What begins as a lighthearted look at the emotional rollercoaster of being a Knicks supporter evolves into a deeply human portrait of love, resilience, and shared identity forged through years of disappointment. Jess recounts the 2019 NBA draft night when her then-boyfriend Lee collapsed in despair after the Knicks missed out on Zion Williamson — a moment she immortalized by laughing and filming him, only to later realize it was the beginning of a profound connection built on enduring hardship together. The episode dives into the absurdity and joy of championship celebrations, from the chaos of planning for the parade to the surreal moment of a rat the size of a possum in the middle of a celebration. It also explores the cultural phenomenon of celebrity fans like Timothée Chalamet and Taylor Swift, the fine line between fandom and public scrutiny, and the surprising political undertones of a college quarterback’s decision to enter the supplemental draft over staying at Texas Tech. At its core, this is not just a sports story — it’s a meditation on how shared suffering and collective joy define community, identity, and love in the face of uncertainty.
Being a Knicks fan isn't about winning — it's about enduring together, and that endurance is what deepens love and loyalty.
The 2019 draft night collapse of Lee Smetana was the emotional origin story of their relationship — a moment of shared vulnerability that became a foundation of trust.
Celebrity fandom is real, but it comes with risks: public backlash can erupt instantly, especially when fans of powerful pop stars like Taylor Swift are criticized.
The decision for Brendan Sorsby to enter the supplemental draft may have been driven more by institutional pressure than personal choice, highlighting how college sports can force difficult decisions under scrutiny.
The 'Freddie the Super Fan' phenomenon may be organic, but it also functions as a soft-power marketing tool — a modern-day cultural ambassador for American quirks like Buc-ee's.
…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus
The World Cup as Identity
The episode opens with a poetic reflection on why people watch the World Cup — not for the game, but for the culture, family, and emotional connection it represents. It's framed as a ritual, a bond passed from generation to generation.
The 2019 Draft Night That Started It All
“When the Pelicans got the first ping pong ball... Lee and his friend Dave just both sank to the ground. And I just stood there and laughed at them.”
The Emotional Toll of Being a Knicks Fan
Jess and Stugotz explore how years of disappointment have shaped their relationship and fandom. The Knicks' recent success feels surreal, almost disbelieving — like they’ve been granted a second chance.
The Paradox of Fan Support: Jinxing and Reverse Jinxing
The hosts discuss the psychological rituals of fandom — from avoiding watching games together to making plans to leave town to 'reverse jinx' the team. Jess admits she stayed in NYC to avoid breaking her own curse.
Celebrity Fans and the Danger of Public Scrutiny
The episode examines how public figures like Timothée Chalamet and Taylor Swift are treated as authentic fans — but their presence can spark backlash, especially when they're criticized for not being 'diehard' enough.
“It truly, it didn't phase me because I was like, I love New York so much. This rat the size of a possum could do whatever it wants to me right now and there's nothing I would do about it.”
“I'm not saying that he's in the CIA but I'm saying if I were in the CIA that's probably what I would do.”
“hope that it was just someone making an adult decision in the room and saying like this is what's best for you and you should do this”
Host
Guest
New York Knicks
other
Lee Smetana
person
Stugotz
person
Jess Smetana
person
Texas Tech
other
Freddie the Super Fan
person
Brendan Sorsby
person
Big 12
other
Taylor Swift
person
Jalen Brunson
person
Victor Wembanyama Has Officially ARRIVED | Local Hour (feat. Michelle Beadle)
42m • 6/1/2026
JuJu's Top 5 TV Shows To Watch | Postgame Show
15m • 6/1/2026
The NBA Finals Matchup Nobody Saw Coming | Alley Oop 188
23m • 6/2/2026
Trust the stars - 6.3.26
22m • 6/3/2026
Who Is The ACTUAL CEO Of This Company? | Hour 1
40m • 6/4/2026
The Best of The Week of Stugotz and Company LIVE!
50m • 5/30/2026
Set 1: Maximum Stugotzed
27m • 6/1/2026
Set 2: Dismantling Chet (w/Shea Serrano)
26m • 6/1/2026
Encore: We Can Observations
16m • 6/1/2026
The Best of Stugotz and Company LIVE!
38m • 6/1/2026
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime