376 - Jim Hartsell: A Round of Scottish Courses

The Cookie Jar Golf Podcast54mJune 2, 2026
AI-Generated Summary

Jim Hartsell, author of 'A Round of Scottish Courses,' argues that the soul of golf lies not in billion-dollar championship links but in Scotland's forgotten, low-cost, community-driven courses—places where history, human connection, and natural beauty converge. He reveals that these hidden gems, like Corey and Whiting Bay, are not just golf courses but living museums of 19th-century design, preserved by passionate locals and untouched by commercialization. What makes them special? They’re built on the land’s natural contours, require no earth-moving, and foster genuine camaraderie—where a greenskeeper might beat you with a nine iron and a putter, and a stranger becomes a friend over a post-round drink. Hartsell’s book, crafted from decades of research, old postcards, and conversations with members who’ve played for 50 years, is a love letter to this authentic golf. He’s not anti-Prestwick or Muirfield—just pro-keeping the game human. And if 100,000 people buy the book, he’ll spend a month in England chasing Bernard Darwin’s footsteps with co-host Stephen Proctor. The real takeaway? Golf’s most profound moments aren’t on the leaderboard—they’re in the punch-bowl greens, the hand-drawn course guides, and the quiet joy of walking a course that hasn’t changed since 1895.

Key Takeaways
1

Play golf at courses that haven’t changed since 1895—like Corey on Arran, where greens are perfect and the greenskeeper is a local legend.

2

The most meaningful golf experiences happen at small, community-run clubs, not high-cost championship courses.

3

Old postcards from the 1890s and 1900s are the only surviving photos of some historic Scottish courses—Hartsell collected them for three years to use in his book.

4

A greenskeeper who’s won the island championship can beat you with just a nine iron and a putter—this is golf at its most human.

5

Hartsell’s book is designed to look like it was published in the 1920s, using only vintage imagery to evoke time travel.

…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus

Chapters
0:00
2 min

Welcome Back: Jim Hartsell Returns

Sam welcomes Jim Hartsell back to the podcast, reflecting on the passage of time since their last episode and setting the stage for the discussion of his new book, 'A Round of Scottish Courses.'

1:50
1 min

The Book Launch and the Recovery

Jim shares his recent book launch events in Scotland, including a party at Denaverty Golf Club, and describes the emotional and physical toll of travel, followed by a rapid recovery and eagerness to return.

3:01
1 min

The Love of Books and Time Travel

Jim explains his deep affection for books, describing them as time machines that bring back memories through notes, receipts, and old covers, and how reading provides mental calm after a hectic day.

4:10
1 min

The Power of Golf as a Social Connector

Jim reflects on how golf uniquely fosters deep, lasting friendships through shared experiences on the course, contrasting it with other sports and emphasizing the value of conversation and connection.

5:23
2 min

The Vision Behind 'A Round of Scottish Courses'

Jim introduces the core idea of his new book: celebrating small, historic, low-cost Scottish courses that preserve the authentic spirit of golf, contrasting them with expensive, commercialized links.

High-Impact Quotes
I mean, when you're out there on a sunny day and you're standing on that second fairway and you look up the Glen, Glen Sannix, up toward the mountains, you think this doesn't look real. This looks like some computer generated thing that somebody's come up with.
Jim Hartsell14:32
There were 12 golf courses on this little island. Sam, I don't know. I say this in the book. I don't know if that's one golf course for every 40 people, 50 people. I can't remember right now, but it's something ridiculous.
Jim Hartsell50:06
Well, there's nothing wrong with strokes there, but it's totally different than that. And I'll send you the one that I did for Iona. They've sold, I don't know, hundreds of them. They've made money to buy a new lawnmower from it.
Jim Hartsell49:28
Speakers

Host

Sam

Guest

Jim Hartsell
Topics Discussed
scottish golf courses95%small golf courses90%golf history88%golf architecture85%hand-drawn course guides82%golf community80%lost golf courses78%golf sustainability75%
People & Brands

Jim Hartsell

person

120xPositive

Sam

person

45xPositive

A Round of Scottish Courses

book

35xPositive

Greg McRae

person

20xPositive

Corey

other

18xPositive

Stephen Proctor

person

15xPositive

Denaverty Golf Club

other

15xPositive

Whiting Bay

other

12xPositive

Try

other

10xPositive

Aberfoyle

other

8xPositive

Start discovering podcast insights today

Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.

No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime