Erin & Sara Foster on Finding Success on Their Own Timeline
Erin and Sarah Foster, sisters and co-creators of the hit Netflix series *Nobody Wants This*, reveal how their journey to success wasn't a straight line but a series of pivots born from vulnerability, self-honesty, and radical acceptance of who they truly are. Far from being overnight sensations, they spent years navigating identity crises, fertility struggles, and the pressure to conform—only to find clarity when they stopped chasing perfection and started embracing their authentic selves. The breakthrough came not from a grand plan, but from a single, unassuming T-shirt labeled 'Favorite Daughter' that sold two million units, sparking a fashion brand rooted in self-acceptance and California cool. Their story is a masterclass in how failure, fear, and even trauma can become fuel when paired with a partner who balances your weaknesses—Erin’s fearless optimism counterbalancing Sarah’s anxiety and perfectionism. At the heart of their success is a radical philosophy: true power comes not from controlling outcomes, but from surrendering to the process, trusting that life will deliver what you’re meant to do—just not in the way you expect. The sisters also share deeply personal revelations: Sarah’s four-year journey into therapy, her decision to leave a long-term relationship for self-honoring reasons, and Erin’s 81,000 IVF rounds, which she endured with a faith that her life would unfold as it should—even if it meant becoming a stepmom at 41.
Success often comes not from a linear path but from embracing pivots and detours that feel like failure at the time.
True authenticity is not about being perfect—it’s about owning your flaws and turning them into a brand’s superpower.
The most powerful partnerships are built on complementary strengths: one person’s fearlessness balances the other’s anxiety.
Fertility struggles and emotional healing are not setbacks—they’re necessary chapters in building self-worth and agency.
Faith isn’t about certainty—it’s about trusting the process, even when the outcome looks nothing like your original plan.
…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus
A Friendship Reborn: Gwyneth’s Deep Connection with the Foster Sisters
Gwyneth Paltrow reflects on her evolving friendship with Erin and Sarah Foster, highlighting how their shared values and deep conversations—especially through the 'non-toxic mom chat'—have brought them closer than ever. The sisters' authenticity and passion for a meaningful life have made them essential confidantes.
From Floating to Focused: The Pivotal Shift to Clarity
The sisters discuss their long period of uncertainty—trying acting, writing, and entrepreneurship without a clear direction—before finally finding clarity through openness to new opportunities, even when they didn’t align with their original dreams.
Erin’s Late Start and the Power of Openness
Erin shares how her late entry into professional writing at 29, followed by repeated rejections, taught her that being open to unexpected paths—like creating a reality show or joining Bumble—eventually led her to her true calling.
Sarah’s Fear of Failure and the Weight of Being the Firstborn
Sarah reveals how her upbringing as the eldest daughter instilled a deep fear of failure and a need for perfection, making her resistant to new ventures—until she learned to lean on Erin’s fearless energy.
The Accidental Birth of Favorite Daughter
“We did favorite daughter, put a little heart on it, and two million dollars of sales in one t-shirt.”
“we do favorite daughter put a little heart on it and two million dollars of sales in one t”
“I had a really strong faith that it was going to work out. And I can only think of the comparison to finding my partner because when I was flailing and going on bad dates and not in a place where”
“I was saying to somebody you, like, I'm not going to just now, well, I will toot your horn a little bit, but you are at the forefront of pivoting and doing things where you don't know how people are going to receive it.”
Host
Guests
Erin Foster
person
Sarah Foster
person
Nobody Wants This
other
Gwyneth Paltrow
person
Favorite Daughter
brand
Judaism
other
Simon
person
Bumble
brand
Ollie Opes
person
Steve Levitan
person
The Actress Draft and Tournament Preview
2h 20m • 6/1/2026
Anduril Founder Trae Stephens on Our Modern Defense System
1h 10m • 6/2/2026
Becoming an Iron Maiden, Self Defense for Women, Overcoming Grief, Finding Your Faith, and More…
2h 15m • 6/3/2026
Ep. 2440 - The California Election Is Corrupt, Just Not How You Think
1h 8m • 6/8/2026
Esoteric Systems: Why We Are Drawn To Them and How We Can Use Them to Serve Our Lives
1h 1m • 6/9/2026
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime

