Go Low - U.S. Open Preview, Scottie vs. Rory Showdown?, Best Bets & Mailbag

The Herd with Colin Cowherd43mJune 17, 2026
AI-Generated Summary

The U.S. Open at Shinnecock Hills is shaping up to be a brutal test of mental toughness, with wind and tough course conditions expected to separate the elite from the pretenders. Host John Middlecoff argues that this year’s setup favors ball-strikers who can control their trajectory—especially low, penetrating shots—over pure power players. He makes a bold case that Rory McIlroy, not Scottie Scheffler, is the favorite to win, citing McIlroy’s recent transformation in shot shaping and mental resilience, particularly in windy conditions. While Scheffler’s career Grand Slam pursuit adds drama, Middlecoff questions whether his emotional volatility under pressure could derail him. The episode also dives into the fallout from the Liv Golf collapse, with Middlecoff predicting that players like Bryson DeChambeau and Jon Rahm will face steep penalties and likely won’t return to the PGA Tour. He calls the Liv experiment a failure driven by oil money, not belief in the product. Meanwhile, he praises Xander Schauffele’s calm demeanor and Tommy Fleetwood’s international grit as key factors in surviving the U.S. Open’s chaos. The most provocative take? Watching Bryson DeChambeau struggle is better TV than watching him win—his emotional outbursts and meltdowns make for must-see content.

Key Takeaways
1

Rory McIlroy is the top pick to win the U.S. Open due to his improved low-trajectory shot control and mental resilience in wind.

2

Scottie Scheffler’s emotional volatility under pressure could derail his Grand Slam pursuit despite a strong season.

3

Bryson DeChambeau is not expected to return to the PGA Tour, with the Liv Golf collapse likely ending his professional career.

4

Xander Schauffele’s calm demeanor and consistency make him a top 10 contender, even if not a favorite.

5

Tommy Fleetwood’s international experience and ball-striking ability give him an edge in tough, windy conditions.

…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus

Chapters
2:23
2 min

The U.S. Open at Shinnecock: A Mental Battle

This is a tournament that just tests you mentally, right? Regardless on a yearly basis.

Highlight
9:51
2 min

Scottie vs. Rory: The Electric Showdown

If he gets off on a couple holes and the pressure of this major, does it derail him?

Highlight
13:33
2 min

Rory’s Comeback: The Best Version Yet

I would say the U.S. Open is something he's kind of figured out.

Highlight
16:54
2 min

Xander and Fleetwood: The Grinders of the U.S. Open

He doesn't show that much emotion when he gets a bogey different from when he fucking knocks it stiff and has a tap-in birdie.

Highlight
23:49
4 min

Betting Picks and the Liv Golf Fallout

Middlecoff shares his betting strategy—Rory to win, Fleetwood and Fitzpatrick to top 10—while dissecting the collapse of Liv Golf and its impact on players.

High-Impact Quotes
And honestly, he doesn't show that much emotion when he gets a bogey different from when he fucking knocks it stiff and has a tap -in birdie.
John Middlecoff18:11
If he gets off on a couple holes and the pressure of this major, does it derail him?
John Middlecoff12:56
But the one thing I would say is, this is a tournament that just tests you mentally, right? Regardless on a yearly basis.
John Middlecoff5:48
Speakers

Host

John Middlecoff
Topics Discussed
u.s. open golf95%liv golf90%bryson dechambeau88%scottie scheffler85%phil mickelson80%xander schauffele78%tommy fleetwood75%ryder cup70%
People & Brands

ryder mcilroy

person

18xPositive

scottie scheffler

person

15xNeutral

iheartradio

organization

12xNeutral

john middlecoff

person

12xNeutral

liv golf

organization

11xNegative

bryson dechambeau

person

10xNegative

phil mickelson

person

9xNegative

xander schauffele

person

8xPositive

tommy fleetwood

person

7xPositive

timbo

person

6xNeutral

Start discovering podcast insights today

Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.

No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime