Our Favorite Picks From Every Round of the 2026 NFL Draft

In this episode of The McShay Show, hosts Mike and Steve Mench break down their favorite picks from the 2026 NFL Draft, analyzing 14 standout selections across seven rounds. They emphasize the value of post-draft analysis, noting how initial reactions can shift with deeper study of trades, roster needs, and player fit. Key highlights include the Dallas Cowboys' strategic selection of Caleb Downs at No. 11, praised for his versatility and mental toughness, and the Cleveland Browns' masterful draft strategy—trading down from No. 6 to secure Spencer Fano and multiple future picks, significantly strengthening their offensive line. The Patriots’ second-round pick of Gabe Ackes, a high-impact edge rusher with a wrestling background, is lauded for addressing a critical defensive need. The episode also celebrates overlooked gems like the Colts’ seventh-round haul of Dion Burks and Seth McGowan, both seen as potential impact players despite injury concerns or late-round status. The hosts stress the importance of long-term development, especially for high-risk, high-reward picks like Taylor Green and Micah Morris. They praise teams like the Saints and Panthers for addressing skill-position depth and offensive line needs with smart, value-driven selections. Overall, the episode reflects a shift in perspective: what seemed like questionable picks during the draft process often reveal themselves as masterstrokes with time. The hosts express optimism about the direction of several franchises, particularly the Browns and Cowboys, whose aggressive, forward-thinking moves suggest a new era of competitiveness. The episode ends on a reflective note, underscoring the value of patience and analysis in evaluating draft success.