The Way-Too-Early 2027 Mock Draft: Arch Manning Vs. Dante Moore

The McShay Show dives into the 'Way Too Early 2027 Mock Draft,' a speculative look at the upcoming NFL Draft just 359 days out. Hosts Mike McShay and Dan Mensch reflect on the 2026 mock draft’s shortcomings—particularly their overvaluation of quarterbacks like Garrett Nussmeyer and Cade Klubnick—while expressing greater confidence in this year’s class. The episode centers on the emerging quarterback debate between Arch Manning (Texas) and Dante Moore (Oregon), with McShay placing Manning first overall to the New York Jets, Moore third to the Arizona Cardinals, and Lenore Sellers fourth to the Cleveland Browns. They explore the personal and organizational dynamics influencing these projections, including Moore’s decision to return to Oregon for maturity and potential aversion to the Jets due to family legacy and coaching uncertainty. The draft class is lauded for its depth, especially at quarterback, with six in the top 10, and standout positional talent like Jeremiah Smith, who is hailed as a generational wide receiver potentially surpassing Calvin Johnson. The hosts also highlight rising stars in tight end, edge rusher, and wide receiver, emphasizing the draft’s unprecedented talent pool and excitement across all positions. Beyond the mock draft, the episode underscores the evolving nature of NFL scouting, with McShay sharing increased access to team early board data and a commitment to avoiding false hope for prospects. The conversation is laced with humor, personal anecdotes, and a deep passion for the game, including a playful dig at Mench’s love for fish shows and a nostalgic look at music festivals. The show concludes with a strong endorsement of The McShay Report as the premier source for in-depth draft analysis, while reaffirming the hosts’ dedication to transparency, accuracy, and fan engagement. The overall tone is enthusiastic, reflective, and deeply invested in the future of the NFL.