Rachel Goldberg-Polin on Losing a Son in Gaza.

The Political Scene | The New Yorker38mJune 15, 2026
AI-Generated Summary

Rachel Goldberg-Polin, a mother who lost her son Hirsch to Hamas captivity and execution on October 7, 2023, delivers a searing, unflinching account of grief, resilience, and moral clarity in her debut memoir, *When We See You Again*. Her story is not just one of personal tragedy but of a profound commitment to humanity in the face of unimaginable loss. She recounts the final moments before Hirsch’s abduction—his casual goodbye on Shabbat night, the sirens, the silence of his unreturned phone—as a moment that shattered her world. Yet, rather than retreat into anger or despair, she became a global voice for the hostages, advocating not for vengeance but for the return of all lives, Israeli and Palestinian alike. Her most powerful moment came at the Democratic National Convention, where she expected scorn but instead heard 24,000 people chant, 'Bring them home,' a moment of collective empathy that stunned her. Now, living in the 'after'—a world where part of her is buried with her son—she clings to Viktor Frankl’s mantra: 'When you have a why, you can bear any how.' Her mission is not to mourn endlessly, but to transform grief into action, to help rebuild a world that can hold both pain and purpose. What makes her story exceptional is not just the depth of her sorrow, but her refusal to let it define her as a victim. Instead, she frames her pain as a lens through which to see the shared suffering of all civilians caught in war. She rejects the false binary of 'us vs.

Key Takeaways
1

After her son Hirsch was executed after 330 days in captivity, Rachel Goldberg-Polin continued advocating for all remaining hostages until the final release on day 843.

2

She delivered a powerful speech at the Democratic National Convention, expecting hostility but receiving a standing ovation and 24,000 people chanting 'Bring them home.'

3

She refuses to be defined by anger, stating she is 'open to feeling anything'—grief, rage, peace—because the 'chips have flown out the window' after burying her son.

4

Her son Hirsch’s final mantra in captivity was Viktor Frankl’s 'When you have a why, you can bear any how,' which now guides her own life.

5

She lives in Jerusalem not despite the trauma, but because her son believed in being part of the 'fix'—a radical listener committed to dialogue and justice.

…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus

Chapters
0:05
2 min

The Voice of a Nation in Grief

I am the Jewish Jane Doe, she'll tell you. But when her eldest child, her son Hirsch, was taken hostage by Hamas on October 7th, Rachel Goldberg-Polin became the emblematic parent, the most effective spokesman of all the many Israeli relatives whose sons or daughters, parents or grandparents disappeared into the tunnels of the Gaza Strip.

Highlight
2:22
2 min

The Knife in the Chest: Living with Unbearable Loss

I always think, how do you not see this dagger sticking out of my chest? How could someone possibly ask how we are?

Highlight
4:13
4 min

From Parental Instinct to Global Advocacy

Rachel explains how her advocacy began as a reflexive act of love for her son, not a political strategy. After Hirsch’s execution, she continued fighting for the remaining hostages, driven by the belief that their lives still mattered.

7:44
5 min

The Last Shabbat: A Moment Frozen in Time

He turned around in the doorway, and very casually he glanced at me and said, love you, see you tomorrow. And that was a thousand days ago.

Highlight
12:55
7 min

The Horror of the Nova Music Festival

I did once. We could see that Hirsch's left dominant forearm had been blown off. He had managed to make sort of a makeshift tourniquet, but you could very vividly see this jagged bone sticking out from below the tourniquet and he stays sitting.

Highlight
High-Impact Quotes
He turned around in the doorway, and very casually he glanced at me and said, love you, see you tomorrow. And that was a thousand days ago.
Rachel Goldberg-Polin15:29
When you have a why, you can bear any how. When you have a meaning, a purpose, a name, a goal, you can bear any how.
Rachel Goldberg-Polin37:55
I did once. We could see that Hirsch's left dominant forearm had been blown off. He had managed to make sort of a makeshift tourniquet, but you could very vividly see this jagged bone sticking out from below the tourniquet and he stays sitting.
Rachel Goldberg-Polin19:07
Speakers

Host

David Remnick

Guest

Rachel Goldberg-Polin
Topics Discussed
grief and loss95%hostage crisis israel palestine90%moral clarity in war85%victor frankl meaning80%zionism and identity75%post-traumatic resilience70%family and memory65%public mourning60%
People & Brands

Hirsch Goldberg-Polin

person

28xPositive

Rachel Goldberg-Polin

person

12xNeutral

John Goldberg-Polin

person

10xPositive

Hamas

organization

9xNegative

David Remnick

person

8xNeutral

Nova Music Festival

other

6xNeutral

Democratic National Convention

other

5xPositive

Viktor Frankl

person

4xPositive

Anir Shapira

person

3xPositive

Gerda Weissman Klein

person

2xNeutral

Start discovering podcast insights today

Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.

No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime