Progressivism Misunderstood

The Remnant with Jonah Goldberg1h 24mApril 25, 2026

Get the full intelligence

Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “Progressivism Misunderstood” inside PodZeus.

AI-Generated Summary

Jonah Goldberg's episode of *The Remnant* explores the ideological underpinnings of progressivism, challenging its self-image as a morally progressive force while tracing its roots to European intellectual traditions, particularly German pragmatism and eugenics. Drawing on Clarence Thomas's recent speech at the University of Texas, Goldberg argues that progressivism, as a philosophy, is fundamentally at odds with the principles of the Declaration of Independence—especially the idea of natural rights and limited government. He critiques the left's romanticization of theft and radicalism, exemplified by figures like Hassan Piker and a New Yorker writer who defends stealing from Whole Foods, calling it intellectual vandalism. Goldberg also defends the strategic use of blockades in the Iran conflict, warns against court-packing as a political tactic, and reflects on the hypocrisy of progressive claims to moral superiority. He concludes with a call to action for listeners to support *The Dispatch* through subscriptions, emphasizing the need for sustainable funding to maintain high-quality journalism in an evolving political landscape.

Key Takeaways
1

Progressivism is not inherently 'good'—it originated in European intellectual traditions, including racist eugenicist thought, and is philosophically opposed to the Declaration of Independence.

2

The left's embrace of theft and radicalism as moral acts is intellectually bankrupt and disproportionately harms the poor, who bear the brunt of crime and economic instability.

3

Clarence Thomas’s speech is a powerful defense of American founding principles, and the silence of right-wing critics on his praise of Locke and the Declaration reveals a deeper ideological cowardice.

4

The idea that progressivism and American constitutionalism must inevitably collide is overstated—these tensions have coexisted for over a century without collapse.

5

The Dispatch needs more subscribers to sustain its operations, and tasteful sponsorships are a necessary, non-invasive path to growth.

Chapters
0:00
7 min

The Chaos of Moving and the Motor Oil Dilemma

Jonah Goldberg opens with a humorous, self-deprecating anecdote about disposing of unused motor oil from a car he sold years ago, highlighting the absurd bureaucracy of DC's toxic waste disposal system. He contrasts this personal frustration with the larger chaos of urban life, setting a tone of weary realism.

6:40
13 min

The Iran Standoff and the Myth of Strategic Success

Getting the Strait of Hormuz open wasn't the strategic goal of this war because it was already open when the war started. Fixing, quote unquote, fixing a problem that you created and then wanting all of this credit for how brilliant you were to be able to do it.

Highlight
20:00
22 min

The Fraud of Leftist Radicalism: Piker, Theft, and Intellectual Vandalism

I'm just so unbelievably contemptuous, are believably contemptuous of these people. And I really resent the fact that the New York Times and other people, these very, very freaking old ideas.

Highlight
41:40
25 min

Progressivism as a European Import: The Hidden Racism of the Movement

The people pushing and really working out and essentially creating the concept of a minimum wage in the progressive era, big chunk of the reason why people like EA Ross and these other people were doing it was for eugenic purposes.

Highlight
1:06:40
33 min

Clarence Thomas’s Speech and the Silent Right

Where are all the people saying, oh, you stupid cucks? You don't, you know, you still think Locke is good? You know, they're just silent.

Highlight
High-Impact Quotes
I'm just so unbelievably contemptuous, are believably contemptuous of these people. And I really resent the fact that the New York Times and other people, these very, very freaking old ideas.
Jonah Goldberg34:58
Viral: 90.0
The people pushing and really working out and essentially creating the concept of a minimum wage in the progressive era, big chunk of the reason why people like EA Ross and these other people were doing it was for eugenic purposes.
Jonah Goldberg80:06
Viral: 88.0
Where are all the people saying, oh, you stupid cucks? You don't, you know, you still think Locke is good? You know, they're just silent.
Jonah Goldberg119:12
Viral: 87.0
Speakers

Host

Jonah Goldberg
Topics Discussed
Progressivism as a Philosophy95%Clarence Thomas and the Declaration of Independence93%Eugenics and the Origins of Progressive Policy92%Iran Conflict Strategy90%Leftist Intellectualism and Radicalism88%Journalism Sustainability and Subscriptions85%Cultural Hypocrisy and Moral Posturing80%The Role of the Federal Reserve75%
People & Brands

Clarence Thomas

person

22xPositive

Iran

place

18xNeutral

Jonah Goldberg

person

15xNeutral

The Dispatch

organization

14xPositive

Woodrow Wilson

person

12xNegative

Strait of Hormuz

other

10xNeutral

Hassan Piker

person

8xNegative

Richard Ely

person

6xNegative

AEI

organization

5xPositive

Federal Reserve

organization

5xNeutral

Get the full intelligence

Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “Progressivism Misunderstood” inside PodZeus.

Start discovering podcast insights today

Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.

No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime