Answering 3 Reasons Protestants Convert to Catholicism or Orthodoxy

In this episode of Theology Mom, Krista Bontrager addresses three common reasons Protestants consider converting to Roman Catholicism or Eastern Orthodoxy: the appeal of beauty and tradition, the desire for institutional unity, and the promise of doctrinal certainty. She acknowledges the emotional pull of ancient liturgical practices, deep intellectual heritage, and the stability of a visible, unbroken church lineage. However, she argues that these attractions are not sufficient grounds for conversion, as they are subjective and often fail to reflect historical or contemporary realities—such as internal divisions within Catholic and Orthodox churches, theological diversity, and pastoral disagreements. Drawing on her experience as a theologian and apologist, Krista emphasizes that Protestantism's strength lies in its commitment to Scripture alone, the perspicuity of the Bible, and the authority of the historic creeds as interpretive guides, not substitutes for Scripture. She calls on Protestant churches to reclaim their own rich traditions—like the Nicene Creed, corporate confession, fasting, and the liturgical calendar—without abandoning their Reformation principles. Ultimately, she advocates for a vibrant, tradition-rich Protestantism that honors the past while remaining grounded in the clear teaching of Scripture.