Kacie Woody
The tragic case of 13-year-old Casey Woody, abducted and murdered in 2002 after being groomed online by a 47-year-old man posing as a teenager, reveals the terrifying vulnerability of trusting children in the early days of the internet. David Leslie Fuller, a married father from California, spent over two years building false relationships with multiple underage girls across the U.S., using fabricated stories about his ailing aunt to manipulate them into sharing personal details. He targeted Casey specifically—her empathy, trust, and lack of digital caution made her the 'perfect victim.' After abducting her in Arkansas, he held her captive in a storage unit for over 24 hours before killing her and taking his own life. The case exposed a critical gap in law enforcement’s ability to handle cybercrimes at the time, leading to major changes in how online predator cases are investigated. More than two decades later, Casey’s story remains a cautionary tale that continues to educate parents and children about the dangers of online anonymity and the importance of digital vigilance. The episode underscores how a single moment of trust—like a friend asking to sleep over—can be exploited by predators who have meticulously planned their crimes. Casey’s friends, Samantha and Jessica, were left grappling with guilt and trauma, but have since become advocates, sharing her story to prevent future tragedies.
Predators like David Fuller used fake identities and emotional manipulation to groom multiple underage girls over years, targeting those with high empathy and low suspicion.
Casey’s trust in online friends, combined with her lack of digital boundaries, made her vulnerable—she shared her real name, address, phone number, and photos with strangers.
The FBI’s investigation revealed Fuller had visited Arkansas multiple times, scouted Casey’s home, and prepared for the abduction with chloroform, chains, and duct tape.
Fuller’s suicide in the storage unit prevented a trial and denied justice, but his digital footprint led to the first major U.S. case of internet stalking of a minor.
Casey’s friends and family now advocate for digital safety, proving that even in tragedy, a victim’s legacy can save others.
…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus
The Unpredictable Nature of True Crime
The episode opens with a reflection on how true crime reminds us of life’s unpredictability and the importance of preparedness, setting a tone of caution and responsibility.
Introducing the Knockbox: Organizing for the Unexpected
A promotional segment for the Knockbox, a system designed to organize personal and estate information so loved ones can act quickly in emergencies.
Welcome to Episode 504: CrimeCon Reflections
The hosts welcome listeners, reflect on their CrimeCon experience, and acknowledge Patreon supporters, including Charles Thompson from Scotland.
Casey Woody: A Life Cut Short
“Casey was a model child and had deep empathy for others. She was also more trusting than her peers because she had never had a bad experience with anyone before.”
The Online Grooming Begins
Casey’s online interactions with Dave Fagan (real name David Fuller) reveal the early signs of grooming—emotional manipulation, fabricated stories, and increasing intimacy.
“A few feet away in the back of the van was Casey's body. She was on her back with her wrists and ankles chained to the four corners of the van's floor.”
“He told the Democrat Gazette, I can't let this be meaningless. I've got to make it do somebody some good.”
“She was described as a model child and had deep empathy for others. She was also more trusting than her peers because she had never had a bad experience with anyone before.”
Hosts
Casey Woody
person
David Leslie Fuller
person
Rick Woody
person
Samantha Davis
person
Jessica Bradford
person
Scott G.
person
Knockbox
brand
Chime
brand
Quince
brand
GuardSmart Storage
brand
SERIAL KILLER: David Meirhofer
50m • 6/1/2026
This YouTube Prankster Went Too Far - H3 After Dark #65
2h 29m • 6/2/2026
175: Bayrob
1h 36m • 6/2/2026
Long Island Serial Killer Part 3
1h 4m • 6/1/2026
Aaron Goodwin
46m • 6/11/2026
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime

