Joel Guy Jr.

True Crime All The Time1h 3mJune 15, 2026
AI-Generated Summary

Joel Guy Jr., a 28-year-old man who had spent a decade in college without earning a degree, meticulously planned and carried out the brutal murder and dismemberment of his parents during Thanksgiving 2016. What makes the case so chilling is not just the violence—his mother’s head boiled in a pot, his father’s hands left on the bedroom floor, torsos stored in plastic containers—but the cold, premeditated nature of the crime. Evidence revealed in court included a detailed notebook with bullet points on how to commit the murders, dismember bodies, destroy evidence, and even how to profit from life insurance policies. The notebook, found in his backpack at his parents’ home, showed he had begun planning as early as November 7th. Despite his parents’ decision to cut him off financially—after years of supporting his education—Guy Jr. chose murder over responsibility. He was arrested days after his mother failed to show up for work, and though he attempted to represent himself to demand execution, a jury found him guilty in just four days. The judge sentenced him to two consecutive life sentences with parole only after 51 years, calling the crime 'pure evil overkill' and noting the defendant showed no remorse. The episode, released after Thanksgiving, serves as a grim warning about the consequences of entitlement, lack of accountability, and the dangerous potential of unchecked resentment.

Key Takeaways
1

Joel Guy Jr. wrote a detailed 5-page notebook outlining how to murder his parents, dismember their bodies, and destroy evidence—planning the crime weeks in advance.

2

He was arrested just days after his mother failed to show up for work, with wounds on his hands from a struggle with his father during the attack.

3

The judge called the crime 'pure evil overkill' and noted Guy Jr. showed no remorse, appearing 'proud' of his actions during the trial.

4

He was sentenced to two consecutive life sentences with parole only after 51 years—effectively ensuring he will never be released.

5

Guy Jr. tried to collect on his parents’ $696,666.68 life insurance policy while awaiting trial, even demanding interest on the payout.

…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus

Chapters
0:00
2 min

The Fear of Starting a Podcast

The episode opens with a sponsor ad for Shopify, where the hosts reflect on the fear of starting a business or podcast, emphasizing that overcoming doubt was one of their best decisions.

1:28
2 min

Vacation Episode & Patreon Announcement

Fergie announces he’s on vacation for his daughter’s wedding, and the team is releasing a Patreon-exclusive unsolved true crime episode to keep listeners engaged.

6:00
2 min

Introducing Joel Guy Jr. and the Thanksgiving Murders

The hosts introduce Joel Guy Jr., a 28-year-old man who murdered his parents in 2016 during Thanksgiving, setting the stage for a detailed exploration of the crime.

8:20
5 min

The Financial and Emotional Pressure

The episode details how Joel Jr. spent nearly a decade in college without graduating, while his parents paid for everything—including a mortgage to cover his legal troubles.

13:20
7 min

The Final Thanksgiving and the Attack

The family gathered for Thanksgiving, with Joel Jr. staying behind after his sisters left. Authorities believe the murders occurred between Friday night and Saturday midday.

High-Impact Quotes
Gibbs, he found Lisa Guy's severed head in a pot of boiling liquid on the stove. He found Joel Guy Sr.'s severed hands on the floor of the bedroom and he found both of the couple's severed torsos in plastic containers in the bathroom.
Mike Ferguson24:51
The judge said, this is the most extreme abuse of a corpse case I've seen in 25 years. And I hope it's the most serious that I'll see in my career.
Judge Sword59:46
Guy, you look like you're kind of proud of what you've accomplished.
Judge Sword60:41
Speakers

Hosts

Mike FergusonMike Gibson
Topics Discussed
true crime95%murder and dismemberment92%premeditated murder90%family murder88%notebook as evidence87%life insurance fraud85%trial and sentencing80%college dropout75%
People & Brands

Joel Guy Jr.

person

120xNegative

Joel Guy Sr.

person

45xNegative

Lisa Guy

person

42xNegative

Mike Ferguson

person

15xNeutral

Mike Gibson

person

14xNeutral

Judge Sword

person

12xNegative

Knox County Sheriff's Office

organization

10xNeutral

Jeremy McCord

person

8xNeutral

Shopify

brand

6xPositive

Chime

brand

4xPositive

Start discovering podcast insights today

Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.

No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime