The After Show: Stalking Samantha – 13 Years of Terror
A woman stalked for over a decade by a man who escalated from persistent attention to kidnapping and imprisonment in a soundproof bunker—only to be released after a harrowing ordeal—has become a chilling case study in how stalking can spiral into violence. The story of Samantha Stites, detailed in the Hulu docuseries *Stalking Samantha: 13 Years of Terror*, reveals a pattern of obsession that defied repeated rejections, legal protections, and even a six-year restraining order. Despite her efforts to protect herself, the stalker followed her across states, infiltrated her social circles, and ultimately broke into her home. Criminologist Casey Jordan, interviewed on *20/20 The After Show*, explains that stalking is not just about harassment—it’s a form of psychological warfare, often escalating from 'incompetent suitor' behavior to predatory violence. The episode underscores a critical truth: no one should wait for physical violence to act. Early documentation, public confrontation, and immediate legal intervention are essential. With one in five women experiencing stalking in their lifetime, the episode serves as a vital public service, offering concrete steps to recognize red flags and access resources like SPARC and RAINN before it’s too late.
Stalking is a form of psychological violence that can escalate to kidnapping and murder, even without prior romantic relationship.
Document every interaction—use screenshots, emails, and video recordings to create time-stamped evidence before a stalker claims you're 'making it up'.
If someone ignores 'no' repeatedly, follows you, or shows up in your life despite clear rejection, treat it as a serious threat and act immediately.
A restraining order is not a guarantee of safety; the real protection comes from consistent documentation and a support network.
Use a dedicated email for stalker communications and CC a trusted friend to ensure evidence is preserved and time-stamped.
…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus
The Case That Changed the Conversation on Stalking
“He followed her to a whole new town where she relocated after finishing her master's in social work. She got a job in Traverse City, Michigan, and settled there. He followed her there.”
Understanding the Mind of a Stalker
“All stalking is violence. And we talk about, okay, the physical violence might be what we most fear. But I can't even... the psychological and emotional violence of the stalking behavior can be even worse than the fear of physical attack.”
The Power of the Order of Protection
Samantha Stites obtained a rare six-year order of protection after documenting years of harassment. The stalker complied for six years, leading to false security—but the episode warns that compliance doesn’t equal safety.
The Night She Was Taken
“She talks about being fearful she was going to die.”
Red Flags and How to Respond
“Document everything. Even your, and I'm a big believer in say things in front of people, and record everything.”
“The stalker could say, she's making this up. Yeah, yeah. Receipts is what they call it these days. Have receipts. Have a receipt, time date stamp and email yourself every single time and all those screenshots in case you lose your phone.”
“So document everything. Even your, and I'm a big believer in say things in front of people, and record everything.”
“He followed her to a whole new town where she relocated after finishing her master's in social work. She got a job in Traverse City, Michigan, and settled there. He followed her there.”
Host
Guest
Samantha Stites
person
Casey Jordan
person
Christopher Thomas
person
Debra Roberts
person
20/20
media
Hulu
media
SPARC
organization
RAINN
organization
ABC Audio
media
Angie Dodge
person
Stalking Samantha: 13 Years of Terror
1h 24m • 6/13/2026
The After Show: Evil at the Door
27m • 6/1/2026
Blood and Water: Face to Face
34m • 6/3/2026
The After Show: New Updates on the Gilgo Beach Murders
27m • 6/8/2026
Ciara's Summer House Return, Jen Fessler Is Still Devastated Over West & All Of Bravo's New Upcoming Shows
48m • 6/1/2026
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime

